Saatva vs. Beautyrest Black Mattress Comparison: Which Is Best? Update 06/2024

Simmons and Saatva are two of the most well-known names in bedding. Founded in 1870, Simmons introduced its first product, the Beautyrest, in 1925. Although Saatva has only been in the market since 2010, it has already established a loyal following.

This comparison guide will only focus on a few models from each company. Both innerspring and hybrid types are available, as well as the Saatva HD and Saatva Latex Hybrid. This includes Simmons Beautyrest Black, the Simmons Beautyrest Black+Cooling hybrid, and the Simmons Beautyrest Black+Comfort hybrid.

Firmnesses range from mild (3) to medium (5) to medium-firm (6) in Saatva’s four variants (7-8). There are two varieties of Beautyrest Black mattresses: a gentle (4) and firm (5). (6). Mattresses in the center of the 10-point firmness scale, such as a 5 or 6, are preferred by the vast majority of sleepers. While heavier people typically want a stiffer form for support, lighter people prefer a softer type for better contouring.

Each of the Saatva and Beautyrest Black mattresses described above will be covered in this guide. Among other things, it will look at their build quality, operational performance, price, and corporate policies. Finding out more about these mattresses can you in determining which one is most suited to your needs.

Please note: We’ll only be comparing Saatva mattresses that bear the Saatva name in this comparison guide. The Loom & Leaf memory foam mattress, the Zenhaven flippable latex mattress, and the Solaire adjustable airbed are not covered in this guide.

Saatva vs Beautyrest Black: Which is Better for You?

Then, which of these new mattresses is the best fit for your needs? It all depends on how well you slept the night before! See which of the beds on this list might be right for you by checking out the list below.

Who Should Buy Saatva

  • The Saatva is a good choice for those who are seeking for a more affordable solution.
  • For those who sleep in a variety of positions, the Saatva mattress may be the best option. You should be able to easily shift positions on both mattresses, but the Saatva has a little bit more bounce.
  • For those who are concerned about the sleep trial time, Saatva offers nearly twice as many nights as Beautyrest, thus this could be a benefit.

Who Should Buy Beautyrest

  • It’s no secret that hot sleepers appreciate Beautyrest’s extra-cool mattress cover.
  • In my opinion, couples will also like the Beautyrest because of its excellent edge support and amazing motion isolation.. This means that you can use the entire mattress without being disturbed by a snoring partner.
  • If you prefer a firm mattress, the Beautyrest Black is a better choice than the Saatva, which is softer.

With both mattresses, you’ll be able to sleep on your back, stomach, or both if you’re a heavier person. Neither of these beds is quite soft enough for side sleepers. Consider purchasing a mattress that provides extra support in the areas where you feel the most pain. An excellent quality memory foam mattress may be the answer.

Saatva vs Beautyrest Black: Similarities and Differences

Consider how these mattresses compare and contrast before we get started comparing them side by side. Check out our comprehensive Saatva mattress review and Beautyrest Black mattress review for additional in-depth information.

The traditional Saatva and the Beautyrest Black are the center of this assessment, but both Saatva and Beautyrest sell several mattress variants. Mattresses from both of these brands are also available in various firmness levels. Saatva Luxury Firm and Beautyrest Black L-Class Medium will be reviewed.

Main Similarities

  • Both of these mattresses have a lot of bounce and support thanks to their innerspring construction. Combination sleepers will appreciate this, as will those who want a more classic look and feel.
  • Back and stomach sleepers will like the firmness of both mattresses.
  • As for the edges, they’re both strengthened. Because of the increased edge support, these beds will appear larger than they really are.

Main Differences

  • The Beautyrest Black is more expensive, while the Saatva mattress is less expensive.
  • The cooling BlackICETM cover of the Beautyrest Black keeps you more comfortable at night than the Saatva.
  • Saatva’s motion is more clearly isolated by the Beautyrest Black. Because of this, sleeping on the Beautyrest with a restless companion is less likely.

At contrast to Saatva, Beautyrest mattresses are also available in brick-and-mortar locations.

Sizing and Weight Options

Even while weight and size aren’t necessarily the first things you consider when shopping for a mattress, keeping them in mind can have a significant impact on your enjoyment of the mattress.

Larger mattresses are preferred by couples and those who toss and turn a lot since they provide more room for movement. For instance, smaller choices are frequently easier to transport and less expensive. Small-room dwellers, on the other hand, may necessitate a smaller mattress size.

The level of support provided by a mattress can be influenced by its height. Thicker models are usually preferred by larger folks because they provide a deeper level of support and comfort and are less prone to bottoming out. How simple it is to get in and out of bed may be influenced by the height of the bed itself. While some sleepers like a higher bed, others prefer a lower one since it is easier to get in and out of. If you’re shopping for a high-profile model, you may want to look for sheets with deep pockets.

Consider the mattress’s weight, as well. Moving or rotating your mattress on a regular basis might be made easier with a lighter mattress. It’s possible that heavier choices will feel more stable on the ground.


Saatva Classic

  • Height: 11.5″, 14.5″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Split King, California King, Split California King

Saatva HD

  • Height: 15.5″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King

Saatva Youth

  • Height: 10″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full

Saatva Latex Hybrid

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King

Beautyrest Black

Beautyrest Black

  • Height: 13″, 13.5″, 15″
  • Size Options: Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Beautyrest Black + Cooling Upgrade

  • Height: 13″
  • Size Options: Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Beautyrest Black + Cooling + Comfort Upgrade

  • Height: 15″
  • Size Options: Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

A greater selection of mattress sizes is available from Saatva. You can get a Saatva Classic in any of the six conventional mattress sizes, as well as an option for splitting up the king or California king for couples with adjustable beds. Split king sizes are also available for the Saatva HD and Saatva Latex Hybrid. There are no queen or king sizes available for the Saatva Youth as it is designed for children.

While the Beautyrest Black isn’t available in twin, the other regular mattress sizes are. Beautyrest Black mattresses don’t come in split sizes at this time.

Customers opting for a lower-profile bed may prefer Saatva’s offerings over Beautyrest Black’s high-profile versions. The Saatva Youth, at 10 inches, is the slenderest model offered by either company. With a thickness of 15.5 inches, the Saatva HD boasts the most obtrusive design.

Additionally, Saatva’s mattresses tend to be heavier than Beautyrest Black models. There is one notable exception: the Saatva Youth, which is lighter than the other models from any brand.

Despite their similar product offerings, Saatva and Beautyrest Black have significantly diverse product ranges. As a result, there are three firmness options and two height options available for the Saatva Classic. For those who weigh more than 230 pounds, the Saatva HD, the Saatva Latex Hybrid, and the Reversible Saatva Youth are all suitable options. There are fewer options in the Beautyrest Black range, instead focusing on a single design with two options for temperature and feel adjustments.

Construction and Materials Comparison

Some of the most important features that set one mattress apart from another are the materials and structure. These characteristics not only affect the comfort of a mattress, but they also contribute to its long-term usefulness. There are advantages and disadvantages to each of the common materials used in mattresses. A lot may be inferred about a mattress’ materials, even if no two are exactly alike.

It is typical to find coils, polyfoam and memory foam in a mattress. For optimum support and body contouring, several mattress types use a combination of materials.

Most mattresses utilize coils or springs in the support layer, but some models also use them in the transition or comfort layers. Coils and springs in the support layer. Coil layers frequently aid in temperature regulation since air can travel relatively unhindered between springs. In addition, these beds often have additional edge support to increase the usable area of the bed. It is common for couples to find the bounce of a coil system pleasant for sex, although this attribute could also lead to more motion transfer, especially if the bed has a thin comfort layer

In terms of bounce, breathability and pressure-relieving properties of latex, it’s hard to beat. Latex that is made from natural resources is also environmentally friendly. Despite the higher cost, latex mattresses do not provide as much motion isolation as polyfoam or memory foam. All three layers of latex can be used in the core.

It is possible to utilize polyfoam in any part of a mattress. As a result of its ability to conform to the body of the sleeper and alleviate pressure areas, it is preferred by some over memory foam due to its quicker return to shape. While high-density polyfoam can be quite long-lasting, lower-density polyfoam degrades more quickly than some other materials.

Memory foam is commonly used in layers of comfort and transition. Pressure relief that many sleepers compare to a hug is what this material is most known for. Memory foam tends to retain body impressions longer than other materials, making it more difficult for some sleepers to switch positions. Its intimate hug can also trap heat against the sleeper’s body, but certain models employ unique mechanisms to alleviate this drawback..


Saatva Classic

The innerspring of the Saatva Classic is based on a hybrid design. This type has a knit organic cover that allows air to circulate through the sleep surface. The cover is quilted with a luxurious Euro pillow top made of 1.25 inches of polyfoam,.75 inches of fiber fill, and 1 ounce of Dacron.

Additional shaping and support are provided by the addition of two thin foam layers. Mattresses with memory foam lumbar pads and a.625-inch polyfoam layer conform to the shape of the sleeper’s body to alleviate pressure building and encourage healthy spinal alignment.

4 inches of 14.5-gauge coils enclosed in foam form the transition layer. Additional bounce and breathability are provided by this layer, as well as autonomous movement of the coils.

To provide support, springiness, and airflow, 13-gauge hourglass coils are used in both mattresses’ cores. When it comes to core thickness, there is a significant difference between 11.5- and 14.5-inch mattresses. Edge support is provided by a thick layer of firm foam that spans around the entire bed. Finally, a.5-inch loft pad and a.875-inch fiber pad are used as the base of the support system.

Saatva HD

Designed to accommodate larger bodies, the Saatva HD mattress is a hybrid mattress.

The surface of the bed is cushioned by a hand-tufted organic cotton cover that is quilted with polyfoam. The top layer of the comfort system is 1.5 inches of Talalay latex, which cradles the sleeper’s body while keeping a buoyant and responsive feel. In order to prevent sagging and maintain the sleeper’s spine upright, the mattress has five zones of firmness. High density 5 pounds per cubic foot (PCF) memory foam is used in the second comfort layer for further contouring, pressure relief and motion isolation.

The polyfoam transition layer is 2 inches thick and separates the comfort system from the core. The bed’s breathability, support, and bounce are enhanced by the use of offset coils in the core. 12.5 gauge coils are strung through the spring system with 17-gauge helical wire for extra strength and isolation. Extra edge support is provided by polyfoam encasing the mattress.

Saatva Latex Hybrid

Having a thickness of 12 inches, the Saatva Latex Hybrid mattress is classified as a medium firm (6).

Talalay latex is used in the comfort layer because it has a bouncy feel compared to memory foam. Small perforations in the latex promote airflow near the surface, which helps keep the sleeper cool.

A support core of 8-inch pocketed coils is also included in the hybrid. Coil gauge is used to separate the support core into two halves. When people sit or sleep near the mattress’ edges, thicker coils are used to keep them from sinking, while thinner coils are used beneath the sleeping area to give it a softer feel.

Covering the mattress is organic cotton certified by the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS) (GOTS). This certification also applies to the organic wool fire barrier on the bed. A significant authority on organic textile certification is the GOTS.

Saatva Youth

Saatva Youth is a flippable innerspring mattress designed for youngsters. On one side, youngsters aged 3 and up are welcome, while on the other, those aged 8 and up are welcome.

The mattress is supported by a layer of 14.5-gauge bonnell coils located in the middle of the bed. The coil system’s edge is stabilized by a polyfoam encasement around its perimeter.

The polyfoam comfort layer on one side of the mattress is zoned to support the spine of the sleeper. Convoluted high-density polyfoam is layered on the bed’s reverse side to provide additional comfort.

Saatva’s Youth Mattress is covered in an organic cotton cover that is hypoallergenic and breathable. The mattress cover features a water-resistant coating and a waterproof layer inside the mattress to protect it from mishaps.

Simmons Beautyrest Black

Beautyrest Black

This is the most expensive hybrid mattress in the Black collection, the Beautyrest Black. The temperature of the bed’s surface is controlled using a BlackICE 4.0 system. This has a cloth cover designed to feel cool to the touch. Next, the bed uses four layers of comfort to cradle and relieve pressure spots on the body of the sleeper. There are a lot of layers here. 1 inch, 1.5 inches, and. 0.5 inches of polyfoam. 5 inches of memory foam laced with gel.

The mattress’s core is made up of individual coils. The springs give the mattress a little bounce, while the core keeps the mattress cool. Vibrations can be reduced by moving each coil on its own. Extra edge support is provided by polyfoam wrapping around the layer’s perimeter.

Beautyrest Black + Cooling

Like the flagship Beautyrest Black, but with additional cooling qualities, this mattress is a combination of the two. It begins with the same cool-to-the-touch cloth cover as the previous model. A four-layer comfort system that is hidden beneath the surface. RightTemp Memory Foam, Gel-infused Memory Foam, and Polyfoam fill up the mattress. Carbon fiber is included into RightTemp Memory Foam to improve temperature regulation. The mattress is supported by this mechanism, which distributes the weight of the sleeper’s body to alleviate pressure points.

Additionally, this model has a pocketed coil core, which enhances breathability and springiness while reducing motion transfer. The edge is protected by a polyfoam encasement.

Beautyrest Black + Cooling + Comfort

The Beautyrest Black + Cooling + Comfort mattress is a hybrid like the rest of the Beautyrest Black mattresses. Its increased cooling and comfort qualities set it apart from the competition.

Surface-level cooling is provided through a cloth cover that feels cool to the touch. Five levels make up the system of comfort:. One inch polyfoam, two inches gel-infused memory foam, one inch right-temp memory foam, and one inch polyfoam make up 75 inches of GelTouch Foam. Polyurethane GelTouch Foam is a unique polyfoam designed to alleviate pressure and promote airflow. Another unique substance is RightTemp Memory Foam. To keep the bed cool, it is impregnated with carbon fiber. This comfort system is designed to be soft, alleviate pressure, and keep the wearer cool and comfortable. ”

Finally, the Beautyrest Black + Cooling + Comfort mattress’s core is made up of pocketed coils, which provide bounce and breathability. In addition, the coils are encased in pockets, which reduces motion transfer. The coil system is encased in a layer of polyfoam for added edge support.

Average Customer Ratings

An untested mattress may seem like a leap of faith to some. Customer evaluations are a great way to get a sense of how a product might function for you based on the experiences of other people who have used it. As a symbol of trust, you may feel more confident in making your purchase.

When reading customer feedback, keep in mind that comfort is a subjective matter. Customer reviews are sometimes at odds with each other because of their differing comfort levels. If you’re shopping for a mattress, this can be a bit of a challenge, but you can get around it by checking for particular criticism in the customer reviews. Customer satisfaction or dissatisfaction is usually determined in part by the mattress’s performance. You can get a better idea of how a mattress will feel to you if you look for reviews that highlight these factors.


Model Average Rating
Saatva Classic 4.9/5
Saatva HD 4.9/5
Saatva Latex Hybrid
Saatva Youth

Beautyrest Black

Model Average Rating
Beautyrest Black 4.5/5
Beautyrest Black + Cooling Upgrade 4.5/5
Beautyrest Black + Cooling + Comfort Upgrade 4.5/5

In-Depth Ratings

The overall comfort of a mattress is influenced by a variety of factors. The following are some of the most commonly sought-after features in a mattress. Personal demands, preferences, and sleeping habits all factor into how important certain aspects are. However, choosing a mattress that works well for you may help you enjoy a better night’s sleep and wake up less frequently.


Durable mattresses last longer because they resist sagging, indentations, and foam degradation. The most long-lasting mattresses are those made from high-quality materials. Despite their higher price, long-lasting versions may be more cost-effective in the long term. Some people prefer not to look for a new mattress and wish to put off getting a new one for as long as possible.

Motion Isolation

Motion-absorbing mattresses are preferred by those who share a bed with a spouse because they don’t disturb their sleep. It’s possible that a partner’s body vibrates as one person shifts positions in bed. Sleeping on a bed that is well-isolated from movement may result in a better night’s rest. A good way to reduce motion transfer is to use thicker layers of cushioning, especially ones that contain memory foam or polyfoam.


It is possible that a number of variables influence the quality of a mattress’ performance during sexual activity. So many couples prefer versions with layers of coils or latex because they seem more stable and comfortable to sleep on. If you’re looking for anything that’s going to keep you from moving around too much, you may want to look elsewhere. It’s common for couples to look for a mattress with good edge support because it gives them more room to move around on the bed. To be more discrete, some partners may prefer a quieter model that doesn’t make much noise.

Temperature Neutrality

As you sleep, your body generates heat, which can be trapped by some mattresses, while others allow it to dissipate. Those who are prone to overheating at night prefer a model that is designed to keep them cool at night. Due to their breathability, latex and coils tend to be more temperature-neutral than other materials. Additionally, polyfoam’s open-cell structure allows heat to be dissipated. There is a higher risk of heat buildup in memory foam because of the material composition, but this is not a deal breaker for many mattress manufacturers.

Pressure Relief

There are certain people who suffer from aches or pains while they sleep because of their bigger and wider body parts. The hips and shoulders of a sleeper are frequently subjected to undue pressure. The weight of the sleeper is distributed more evenly in pressure-relieving models. Most of a mattress’s pressure reduction comes from its comfort system. Memory foam, polyfoam, and latex are some of the best materials for mattress padding because of their exceptional resilience and comfort.


Mattresses with synthetic foam or compressed shipping often have manufacturing odors trapped in them. A lot of individuals don’t give much thought to off-gassing odors because they’re deemed innocuous. If the mattress is placed in a well-ventilated area for a few days, most odors will dissipate. As a result, those who are sensitive to odors may prefer a model that is less prone to emit an odor.

Ease of Movement

Some people may find it more difficult to get out of a mattress that responds slowly to changes in pressure, hugs the body, and/or allows the sleeper to sink in deeply. As a result of its long response time, memory foam might make some people feel like they’re stuck in their bed. Those with substantial memory foam comfort layers are more likely to suffer from this issue. A type that is simpler to move on may be preferred by persons who have mobility concerns or shift positions frequently while sleeping.

Edge Support

If you frequently sit or sleep on the edge of your bed, you might want to consider a model with a supporting border. As a result, many people will avoid sleeping on the edge of their bed. This restricts the mattress’s useable surface area. With thicker support layers and more rigid models, the edges of these models are more likely to hold up without any further reinforcement. There are a number of models with coil layers that use specific materials and construction processes to provide support around the mattress’s perimeter, though.


Saatva Classic Saatva HD Saatva Latex Hybrid Saatva Youth
Firmness Soft (3), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8) Firm (7) Medium Firm (6) Medium (5), Firm (7)
Durability 4/5 4/5 3/5 3/5
Motion Isolation 3/5 2/5 3/5 3/5
Sex 3/5 4/5 4/5 N/A/5
Sleeps Cool 4/5 5/5 4/5 3/5
Pressure Relief 4/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Off-Gassing 5/5 4/5 4/5 3/5
Ease of Movement 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5
Edge Support 4/5 4/5 4/5 3/5

Beautyrest Black

Beautyrest Black Beautyrest Black + Cooling Upgrade Beautyrest Black + Cooling + Comfort Upgrade
Firmness Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6) Medium Firm (6) Medium Soft (4)
Durability 4/5 4/5 4/5
Motion Isolation 3/5 3/5 4/5
Sex 3/5 3/5 2/5
Sleeps Cool 3/5 4/5 3/5
Pressure Relief 4/5 4/5 4/5
Off-Gassing 3/5 3/5 3/5
Ease of Movement 3/5 3/5 3/5
Edge Support 3/5 3/5 3/5

Prices and Sizing

There are several elements that influence the cost of an item, such as the materials required to make it. It is because of this that larger mattress sizes and thicker versions are usually priced higher.

High-quality and technologically innovative materials frequently cost mattress manufacturers more than other options, and this additional expense is usually reflected in the mattress’s cost.. A mattress is an essential investment, and higher-priced materials may improve the bed’s longevity and comfort for some customers.

The location of a mattress’s manufacturing might also affect its pricing. Due to the higher costs of facilities and personnel, American-made models are frequently more expensive.


Saatva Classic Saatva HD Saatva Latex Hybrid Saatva Youth
Twin $887 $1,574 $1,149 $699
Twin XL $1,087 $1,687 $1,274 $799
Full $1,474 $2,074 $1,649 $899
Queen $1,574 $2,674 $1,849
King $1,974 $2,974 $2,249
California King $1,974 $2,974 $2,249
Split King $2,174 $3,374 $2,548
Split California King $2,174

Beautyrest Black

Beautyrest Black Beautyrest Black + Cooling Upgrade Beautyrest Black + Cooling + Comfort Upgrade
Twin $N/A $N/A $N/A
Twin XL $2249 $2749 $2949
Full $2529 $3029 $3229
Queen $2699 $3299 $3499
King $3199 $3999 $4199
California King $3199 $3999 $4199
Split King
Split California King

Beautyrest Black mattresses are more expensive than Saatva mattresses on average. If you like a mattress that is softer than the usual firmness range, this additional investment may be worth it. Customers who choose long-established brands may also believe that the additional cost is worth it.

The Saatva Youth and the Saatva Classic are the cheapest options from each brand. As a result of its additional features and cutting-edge technology, the Simmons Beautyrest Black + Cooling + Comfort costs the most.

Trials, Warranty, and Delivery



White Glove delivery is included with every Saatva mattress purchased inside the contiguous United States. It is currently not possible for Saatva to ship to Alaska and Hawaii, but a freight forwarder can do so.

Customers’ orders for mattresses are often filled only after they have been made. Mattresses often arrive within a few weeks, but this can vary depending on the location of the customer. Customers may expect a four-hour window in which a delivery staff will bring their new mattress into their home, remove its packaging, set it up, and dispose of their old mattress.

Saatva mattresses can be purchased online from the company’s official website. A New York City viewing room for models may be found at

Simmons Beautyrest Black

White Glove delivery is available in the contiguous United States for Beautyrest mattresses purchased online. At this moment, Beautyrest mattresses purchased online cannot be delivered to Alaska or Hawaii.

Customers can expect a four-hour delivery window from XPO Logistics, the company’s shipping partner. Within 7 to 15 business days of the order being placed, XPO Logistics normally reaches out. Unpack your new mattress and remove the wrapping; they’ll also take away your old one.

The Beautyrest website, Amazon, and select mattress and furniture stores in the United States sell Beautyrest Black mattresses.

Sleep Trial


During the 180-night trial period, consumers can test out Saatva mattresses in the comfort of their own homes. Customers can return the mattress at any point throughout the trial term for a full refund of the purchase price. Saatva will take care of the mattress removal process. An additional transportation cost of $99 is required. Recycled mattresses can be donated or given to distribution center workers.

Replacement mattresses can be exchanged for a $99 transportation cost, and they are qualified for a 180-night sleep trial.

Simmons Beautyrest Black

Simmons Beautyrest Black models come with a 100-night sleep trial when purchased straight from Simmons. When a consumer is not satisfied with their mattress, they can return it and get a full refund. All Simmons customers will receive a mattress removal service at no charge from Simmons. In this arrangement, each household can receive one refund every year.

The return policies of other retailers that sell Beautyrest Black mattresses may vary.


A replacement mattress is usually included in warranty agreements at no additional cost. Most policies cover at least a few years of coverage and protect against some of the most prevalent problems, such as indentations and foam cracking. If a mattress company has a decent warranty program, customers can feel more confident that their purchase will last.

Consider what is expected of you as a customer and what is covered and not covered by the firm’s warranty policy, as well as how the company pledges to remedy faults, while looking at a warranty policy. If a fault arises, these variables may determine whether or not your mattress is eligible for compensation.


The Saatva Youth comes with a 12-year warranty, while the Saatva Classic, Saatva Latex Hybrid, and the Saatva HD each have a 15-year warranty and a 20-year warranty, respectively. For defective materials and craftsmanship, as well as qualified body impressions, these warranties are available. The Saatva Classic and Saatva Youth policies cover body imprints more than 1 inch, while the Saatva HD policy covers impressions greater than 1.5 inches.

Saatva offers free mattress replacements for the first two years of the guarantee period. Saatva will repair and re-cover mattresses with qualifying problems for the remainder of the warranty period for a cost of $99 per way.

A “Fairness Replacement Option” is also offered by the business. Mattresses can be kept by consumers instead of being sent back, and new ones purchased at a prorated fee based on the length of time they’ve had their current mattress. There is a possibility that the customer will be charged for transportation.

Additional terms and conditions may apply. Please read them carefully before signing up.

Simmons Beautyrest Black

Only mattresses manufactured and assembled in the United States are covered by the Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress’ 10-year limited warranty. The original mattress owner is covered by this policy.

You may be eligible for an entire mattress replacement if Simmons finds an eligible issue in your mattress.

Mattresses must be used on a good base and must be free of abuse, misuse, and stains in order to be eligible for warranty coverage. It’s up to the customer whether or not they want to keep the white law tag that is affixed to the mattress. Additional terms and conditions may apply. Please read them carefully before signing up.

What Do These Mattresses Feel Like?

Look closely at how these beds could feel to sleep on top of! To begin, I’d like to discuss the importance of being firm. Depending on your body shape and preferred sleeping position, a mattress’s feel can vary greatly. I’m 5’10” and 190 pounds, and I prefer to sleep on my stomach.


It is possible to choose between a Plush, a Luxury Firm and a firm mattress from the Saatva collection. To my surprise, the Luxury Firm model was quite firm, with an overall firmness rating of 7 out of 10. Medium firmness, as a rule of thumb, is defined as 6.5 out of 10.

The Saatva made me feel safe and secure, as though my spine was properly aligned. As a combination sleeper, I needed a mattress that was easy to move around on, and this one did not disappoint.

I experienced some discomfort in my shoulders and hips while I slept on my side, so I wouldn’t recommend this mattress for those who sleep on their sides. However, stomach sleepers should have the support they require in the hips in order to feel at ease on this mattress.

Beautyrest Black

According to my firmness rating, the Beautyrest Black mattress is a solid 8 out of 10. I found it to be a tad more firm than the Saatva. There is a lot of support in the mattress because to the pocketed coils and strong poly foam transition layer, and the memory foam comfort layer is thin enough to maintain its firmness.

If you sleep on your back or stomach, this mattress is best suited for you. This mattress is ideal for stomach sleepers who want a mattress that is exceptionally firm. Keeping the hips from sinking in helps keep the spine aligned in these poses, which is a good thing. Side sleepers, on the other hand, may find this mattress to be overly firm, resulting in shoulder pain. Beautyrest Hybrid may be a better option for those who sleep on their sides frequently.

Gel memory foam is a feature of the Beautyrest’s top layer, which helps to alleviate pressure points. A good fit for your body is achieved by this layer. In addition, it provides a little degree of motion isolation. This suggests that it could be a hit among couples. A snoring spouse on this bed shouldn’t bother you too much. However, if you’re prone to being bothered by a snoring spouse, a foam mattress may be the better option.

Comparing Saatva and Beautyrest Black Mattress Materials

In order to understand why these beds feel the way they do, let’s take a closer look at each of them one by one.


  • Cover — In addition to being breathable, the Saatva’s organic cotton cover is antibacterial. It’s quite comfortable to the touch.
  • Comfort Layer — The top layer of the Saatva is a euro pillow top. It provides some comfort and relief for those who sleep on their stomachs.
  • Support Layer — Next is a layer of individually wrapped pocketed coils that serves as a foundation. This product provides some bounce, air flow, and support..
  • Zoned Support Layer — Pressure is alleviated in the lower back thanks to the Saatva’s central layer of memory foam. For those who suffer from lower back pain, this is a welcome addition.
  • Foundation Layer — Steel coils form the foundation of the Saatva’s structure. This second layer of coils gives even more tremendous lift and support..
  • Edge Support — High-density foam covers the entire mattress. As a result, the Saatva will enjoy a significant advantage. No matter how far to the side you roll on this mattress, you should still feel supported.

Beautyrest Black

  • Cover — Polyester and rayon make up the cover, which is breathable and cools the bed as you sleep. There are two layers of polyfoam quilted into the mattress, allowing sleepers to sink into the mattress immediately away.
  • Comfort layer — Memory foam with gel is then applied as a final layer. Rather of devouring a sleeper or detracting from the bed’s overall support, it provides a tinge of pressure relief. The gel infusion helps cool a sleeper’s body by drawing heat away from them.
  • Transition layer — The transition layer is constructed of poly foam, which is a little harder than the memory foam that covers the comfort layer. Transitioning from memory foam to pocketed coils is made easier by this layer.
  • Support layer — Pocketed coils provide the mattress’s base layer of support. The mattress’s bouncy and supporting feel is a result of the coils. There are two layers of coils in the Saatva, but just one in the Beautyrest Black.
  • Edge support — It has a similar high-density polyfoam layer to the Saatva, which increases edge support while allowing individuals and couples to use the entire surface area of this bed.

Saatva vs. Beautyrest Black: Best Qualities

Whew! Almost there! We’ve covered construction, feel, and price in our Saatva vs. Beautyrest Black mattress comparison! Which mattress is right for you? Honestly, I don’t know, but the following sections should help you decide!

Saatva Best Features

  • For those who prefer to sleep in multiple positions, the Saatva mattress is ideal. On this bed, it’s simple to change positions at any time during the night.
  • If you sleep on your back or stomach, you’ll love the Saatva’s solid support.
  • The Saatva is less expensive than the Beautyrest for those on a tight budget. It is, in fact, a bargain for a high-end mattress.

Beautyrest Black Best Features

  • For back and stomach sleepers, the Beautyrest Black mattress is ideal since it’s firm and supportive, ensuring that hips and spines remain in proper alignment.
  • Those who are concerned about overheating while they sleep may benefit from this mattress. This mattress has a breathable cover and gel-infused memory foam that keep you cool at night.
  • As a last bonus, couples will appreciate the Beautyrest Black’s cooling technology and additional edge support.

Our Recommendations

Choose the Saatva if…

  • The aches and pains that plague you are on a regular basis.
  • You and your partner prefer to sleep on mattresses that respond to your movements.
  • You’re prone to overheating while you’re asleep.

Choose the Simmons Beautyrest Black Mariela if…

  • You prefer the sturdiness of high-end beds.
  • You and your partner prefer to sleep on mattresses that respond to your movements.
  • You’re prone to overheating while you’re asleep.

Our Review Process

Each mattress is put through its paces by a member of the Sleepopolis team. In order to determine how difficult (or simple) it will be to transfer the mattress from the box into the bed, we begin by unpacking it from its packaging. Afterwards, we’ll spend some time lying on the bed in various positions to see how it feels on our backs, stomachs, and sides, all before making a determination. Next, we conduct our Sleepopolis testing, which use sophisticated equipment to assess motion transmission, bounce, and pressure relief. The final step is to remove each layer of the mattress and inspect them individually. Following these procedures, we’re in a position to render a final judgment on the bed. Recap of the best mattresses we’ve found.

Rate this post