Puffy vs. Leesa Mattress Comparison: Which Is Best? Update 01/2022

The act of researching different brands and models is an important element of purchasing a mattress. The assumption that any mattress will be universally pleasant for all sleepers is a fiction. Each mattress created today is tailored for specific persons based on body type, sleep position, and firmness preferences; the notion that any mattress will be universally comfortable for all sleepers is a myth. Puffy and Leesa are two popular “mattress-in-a-box” brands that specialize in memory foam models.

Puffy opened its doors for the first time in 2017. The Puffy Mattress’s flagship model is a 10-inch model with a memory foam comfort layer on top of denser polyfoam transitional and base layers. Puffy has released two more all-foam mattresses since its beginnings. The Puffy Lux is a 12-inch model that adds a polyfoam comfort layer for added contouring and cushioning to the flagship bed. Three foam comfort layers and a zoned transition layer provide improved support to the torso and waist on the Puffy Royal, which is 14 inches thick. Despite the fact that Puffy mattresses become softer with each additional layer, all three versions are rated as medium (5) stiff. The Lux Hybrid and Royal Hybrid, which contain pocketed coils in their support cores but the same comfort and transitional layers as their all-foam namesakes, were recently added to Puffy’s mattress line.

Leesa was established in 2014. Over a high-density foam base, the Leesa Original is a mixed-foam mattress with a polyfoam comfort layer and a memory foam transition layer. Leesa has since released three more mattresses. Although the Leesa Hybrid has polyfoam and memory foam layers, its support core is made up of pocketed coils. The Leesa Legend is a coil-on-coil hybrid mattress with a microcoil comfort layer, as well as polyfoam and memory foam components and a pocketed coil base. Finally, the Studio by Leesa is a low-cost memory foam mattress with a similar construction to the Puffy Mattress. The Leesa Original has a medium (5) firmness rating, whereas the other three Leesa versions have a medium firmness rating (6).

For comparison shopping, we’ll break down the Puffy vs. Leesa mattresses. We’ll go into the construction, cost, and performance of each of these brands’ models in detail.

Leesa vs. Puffy: Top Similarities

  • They’re both well-liked mattresses with excellent customer service.
  • Both of these mattresses are made entirely of foam and include memory foam in their design.
  • They have identical foundation layers and a hardness that is comparable.
  • They are all priced in the same basic range.

Leesa vs. Puffy: Key Differences

  • Although the Leesa has more layers than the Puffy, the Puffy has a thicker comfort layer.
  • On top of the Leesa is a special latex-like foam, while the Puffy features a gel memory foam.
  • The Leesa features a balanced foam texture, whilst the Puffy has a traditional memory foam texture.

Sizing and Weight Options

One of the first considerations for many mattress buyers is the size. Mattresses are typically sold in six standard sizes nowadays. The twin, twin XL, and full sizes are designed for single sleepers, while the queen, king, and California king sizes are suitable for co-sleepers.

When it comes to mattress-in-a-box products, weight is also a factor. Because these mattresses are brought right to your door, you’ll have to carry the box to the room where you want to use it – and bigger versions may require more than one person.

Finally, you should think about the mattress height – or profile – you like. Some people like to sleep on a low-profile bed (less than 10 inches above the ground), while others prefer the added padding of a high-profile mattress (more than 12 inches). A medium profile (10 to 12 inches) is a decent balance for many sleepers.

Puffy

Puffy Mattress

  • Height: 10″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Puffy Lux

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Puffy Royal

  • Height: 14″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Puffy Lux Hybrid

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Puffy Royal Hybrid

  • Height: 14″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Leesa

Leesa Original Mattress

  • Height: 10″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Leesa Hybrid Mattress

  • Height: 11″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Leesa Legend

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Studio by Leesa

  • Height: 10″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

The majority of Puffy and Leesa mattresses are available in all six normal sizes, with the exception of the Leesa Legend, which is not available in a twin size. Both brands do not provide specialty sizes such as full XL or split choices. If carrying the mattress is a worry, Puffy and Leesa both provide various queen-size models that weigh 75 pounds or less, which is considered light. Both the Leesa Hybrid and the Leesa Legend weigh at least 100 pounds and are more difficult to lift and carry. In a queen size, all Puffy models weigh around 100 pounds, but the hybrids are much heavier than the all-foam variants.

Puffy and Leesa, too, have a variety of profiles. The Puffy Lux, Puffy Lux Hybrid, Puffy Royal, Puffy Royal Hybrid, and Leesa Legend are all high-profile mattresses that should fit anyone looking for a thicker mattress with more cushioning layers. The Puffy Mattress, Leesa Original, Leesa Hybrid, and Studio by Leesa are likely to be more comfortable for consumers looking for a medium-profile bed.

Construction and Materials Comparison

Pay particular attention to the materials used in each layer of a mattress while comparing them. The construction and material composition of a bed can have an impact on its pricing and overall feel, as well as its durability, edge support, pressure relief, and other performance characteristics.

For Puffy and Leesa mattresses, we’ll break down the layers and materials.

Puffy

Puffy Mattress

A 2-inch comfort layer of proprietary CloudComfort memory foam is included in the Puffy Mattress’s flagship model. The foam conforms well to the medium (5) firmness of the mattress. This results in the sinking, body-cradling sensation that has become synonymous with memory foam mattresses. Although the memory foam is injected with gel to assist cool the surface, we found that the mattress still absorbs and traps body heat to a significant degree — a frequent problem with memory foam beds.

A 2-inch transitional polyfoam layer maintains the comfort layer and prevents you from sinking too far, while a high-density polyfoam support core stabilizes the entire mattress. The Puffy Mattress is Puffy’s shortest mattress, measuring 10 inches thick in total.

Puffy Lux

The Puffy Lux has a thickness of 12 inches. This mattress features a plusher surface feel than the flagship model, allowing for greater contouring. A 1.5-inch comfort layer of gel-infused CloudComfort memory foam is layered over a second 2-inch comfort layer of adaptable polyfoam to achieve this. A transitional polyfoam layer and a high-density polyfoam base are also included in the mattress.

Puffy Lux Hybrid

The Puffy Lux Hybrid, like the all-foam Lux, is 12 inches thick and has a medium (5) feel. The comfort and transitional layers of the hybrid are the same as those of the foam equivalent. The support core architecture is the fundamental distinction between these two variants. The Lux Hybrid uses pocketed coils instead of foundation foam, which gives it a firmer, more responsive feel without sacrificing the pressure-relieving capabilities of the foam layers. This makes the Lux Hybrid a fantastic choice for consumers who want their mattress to provide cushioning and contouring while also enjoying the feel of a slightly bouncy surface.

Puffy Royal

The Puffy Royal is considerably thicker and plusher than the Puffy Lux, yet it still has a medium feel to it by our standards. 1.5 inches of gel-infused memory foam, 2 inches of polyfoam, and a third polyfoam layer that provides both more cushioning and transitional reinforcement make up the comfort layers. Because this mattress moulds to your body more closely than the other two Puffy types, you’ll experience a deep, body-cradling sensation as the foam molds to your shape.

The transitional layer of the Puffy Royal is zoned, which means it is firmer beneath the chest, lower back, and hips while cradling the head and neck, shoulders, and legs. Despite the fact that the Puffy Royal’s zoned foam is designed to provide improved support, many back and stomach sleepers sink quite a bit due to its extremely close shape. A 7-inch high-density polyfoam support core is also included in the mattress.

Puffy Royal Hybrid

In terms of thickness, firmness, and comfort/transitional layer structure, the Puffy Royal Hybrid is similar to its all-foam counterpart, the Lux Hybrid. The Royal Hybrid’s support core is made up of pocketed coils rather than base foam. Although the upper foam layers are thick enough to give close contouring and relieve pressure for some sleepers, the Royal Hybrid offers more support and responsiveness than the all-foam Royal.

The coverings of all Puffy mattresses are composed entirely of polyester. These covers can be unzipped, removed, and washed in any household washer, though Puffy recommends just washing and drying them every few months to keep the fabric from wearing out. The covers are OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certified, which means they are free of toxic chemicals and other harmful materials.

Leesa

Leesa Original

A 2-inch comfort layer of low-density polyfoam plus a 2-inch transitional layer of low-density memory foam make up the Leesa Original. When comparing the flagship Leesa mattress to the Puffy mattress, polyfoam is a touch more responsive than memory foam and won’t contour as precisely, thus the former feels a little more bouncier and supportive. Indentation load deflection (ILD) for the polyfoam comfort layer is 13, whereas ILD for the memory foam is 9. Both of these statistics suggest a rather soft feel and close contouring; foam ILD in beds with stronger sensations can reach up to 40.

The Leesa Original is somewhat breathable thanks to the reduced density of its comfort and transitional foams, as higher-density foams absorb and trap more body heat. Lower foam density, on the other hand, is linked to shorter mattress lifespans, thus you might see your Leesa Original’s foam layers produce impressions with time. A 6-inch support core constructed of 1.8 PCF high-density polyfoam is included in the mattress.

Leesa Hybrid

A top 1.5-inch layer of low-density polyfoam and a second 1.5-inch layer of medium-density memory foam make up the Leesa Hybrid’s comfort layers. The Leesa Hybrid has a medium firm feel and won’t wear out as rapidly as the flagship Leesa mattress because the second layer is a bit thicker and firmer. A transitional polyfoam layer adds additional support to keep you from sinking too far.

The 6-inch support core of the Leesa Hybrid has pocketed coils. The interior coils have a gauge of 14.5, signifying a medium thickness and moderate level of support, while thicker coils ring the perimeter of the mattress to reinforce the edges. As a result, when going on and off the mattress, you shouldn’t sink too much. The coil layer is bolstered by a 1-inch layer of high-density foundation polyfoam for extra stability.

Leesa Legend

Another hybrid model is the Leesa Legend. Aerated polyfoam makes up the top 1-inch comfort layer, which enables good airflow at the surface for enhanced cooling. A second 1-inch comfort layer of memory foam and a third 1.5-inch comfort layer of microcoils zoned with polyfoam are also included in the mattress. The memory foam contours to the body for a snug fit, while the zoned microcoils provide additional support and make the surface more sensitive. For individuals who enjoy bouncy mattresses, this is a good alternative.

The transitional polyfoam layer is also zoned to cradle lighter areas and reinforce portions of the body where people tend to carry a disproportionate amount of weight, such as the stomach and hips. As a result, the Leesa Legend is well-suited to side and back sleepers of various weight categories. Its interior pocketed coils feature a gauge of 15, making them slightly thinner than the Leesa Hybrid’s, but thicker coils assist reinforce the mattress’s perimeter.

Leesa Studio

Finally, the Leesa Studio is the company’s newest mattress model. This is also the only Leesa bed with a memory foam top comfort layer. The Studio by Leesa, unlike the other Leesa mattresses, has a more classic memory foam feel, with deep contouring and a delayed response. Overall reinforcement is provided by a transitional polyfoam layer and a high-density polyfoam support core. With a medium firm feel, this mattress will provide greater support for persons who weigh 130 pounds or more.

The materials used in Leesa’s covers differ depending on the model. Polyester-blend covers are used on the Leesa Original, Leesa Hybrid, and Studio by Leesa. Polyester, plastic from recycled bottles, organic cotton, merino wool, rayon, and spandex make up the fabric blend for the Leesa Legend’s cover. For cleaning purposes, none of the Leesa mattress coverings should be removed. If stains do emerge, the brand recommends spot cleaning with a light detergent and lukewarm water.

Average Customer Ratings

When comparing mattresses, customer evaluations can be really useful — to a point. Actual mattress owners’ evaluations can provide insight into how the bed feels and functions, as well as point out mistakes and exaggerations in the company’s claims of the mattress. However, each evaluation is based on the subjective experiences of one or two people. Pay attention to patterns in several reviews, but keep in mind that your experience with a mattress may be quite different from that of a reviewer.

Independent consumer watchdogs such as the Better Business Bureau (BBB) award letter grades to particular companies based on their customer service and reactions to various customer complaints, so you can discover more about the brands themselves.

Most online mattress retailers make customer reviews with various star ratings easy to find, however some make unfavorable reviews more difficult to find. Mattress ratings for each Puffy and Leesa model are provided below, based on our extensive research of reviews for both manufacturers.

Puffy

Model Average Rating
Puffy Mattress 5/5
Puffy Lux 5/5
Puffy Royal 5/5
Puffy Lux Hybrid
Puffy Royal Hybrid

Leesa

Model Average Rating
Leesa Original Mattress 4.5/5
Leesa Hybrid Mattress 4.5/5
Leesa Legend 4.9/5
Studio by Leesa 4.6/5

In-Depth Ratings

Based on how firm it feels, how thick its profile is, and the materials used to make its numerous layers and components, each mattress has its own set of benefits and drawbacks. We rated each Puffy and Leesa mattress based on the following performance categories based on sleeper comments and our own testing.

Durability:

The average mattress will last 6 to 8 years before it needs to be replaced. The fabrics in the comfort, transitional, and support layers will deteriorate over time. You may sense a loss of shape on the surface, reduced support from the base layers, and greater sinkage when getting in and out of bed as this happens. Innerspring and all-foam mattresses, on average, have the shortest lifespans of all mattress kinds, lasting six to seven years. Hybrids have an average lifespan of six and a half years.

Motion Isolation:

When you change positions or go on and off the bed, certain mattresses have components that absorb movement and prevent it from traveling across the surface and disrupting your sleep companion. You and your partner will sense more movement on the surface if the mattress is responsive due to particular components – such as latex or coils – and may experience sleep difficulties as a result.

Sex

For sex, the majority of couples prefer responsive, gently contoured mattresses. You and your partner will be able to move freely without sinking too deeply thanks to the extra bounciness on the surface, but some conforming will ensure strong traction if you want to stay in one position for a longer amount of time. Another factor to consider is edge support. You and your partner may feel restricted to the middle of the mattress if the edges are weak and deep sinkage is possible.

Temperature Neutrality

Solid foam layers in mattresses tend to absorb and trap body heat, making sleepers feel overheated. Other materials are more breathable and facilitate airflow, which aids in the mattress’s temperature regulation. Foam or latex layers with microscopic holes for ventilation, coil systems that pump air currents throughout the inside, and covers laced with cooling textiles and fibers are just a few examples. Deep contouring can shut off surface airflow for sleepers, which might affect temperature neutrality.

Pressure Relief

How efficiently (or poorly) a mattress relieves pressure points is determined by your weight and preferred sleeping position. The finest pressure-relieving mattress will support your lower back, cushion your heavier areas without sinking too much, and promote even spinal alignment. People who weigh less than 130 pounds prefer softer, more conforming mattresses, whereas those who weigh more than 230 pounds prefer firmer, more supportive mattresses.

Off-gassing

When you remove a mattress from its shipping box, the foam layers usually exude perceptible off-gassing. These odors are caused by volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which are small particles with a characteristic chemical odor. The odours should go away in a few days, but beds with substantial foam layers may take longer to air out. If the scents continue after a few days, try putting the mattress in a well-ventilated area to get rid of them.

Ease of Movement

Deeply sunk beds can be difficult to move across; many individuals describe the sensation as being stuck in the mattress. If a bed sinks too much, it will be difficult to get on and off the mattress, and you may also feel uncomfortable when changing sleep positions. This isn’t a problem with firmer, more responsive mattresses.

Edge Support

When you sit or lie at the borders of most beds, they sink a little. To give greater push-back and prevent excessive sinkage, some mattresses reinforce the perimeter with thick coils, dense foams, and other supportive materials. Softer mattresses with less durable edge materials, on the other hand, will most likely sink quite a bit, and this problem may intensify over time, leading to increased instability.

Puffy

Puffy Mattress Puffy Lux Puffy Royal Puffy Lux Hybrid Puffy Royal Hybrid
Firmness Medium (5) Medium (5) Medium (5) Medium (5) Medium (5)
Durability 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Motion Isolation 5/5 5/5 5/5 4/5 4/5
Sex 2/5 2/5 2/5 3/5 3/5
Sleeps Cool 2/5 2/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Pressure Relief 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5
Off-Gassing 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Ease of Movement 2/5 3/5 2/5 3/5 3/5
Edge Support 3/5 3/5 2/5 3/5 3/5

Leesa

Leesa Original Mattress Leesa Hybrid Mattress Leesa Legend Studio by Leesa
Firmness Medium (5) Medium Firm (6) Medium Firm (6) Medium Firm (6)
Durability 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Motion Isolation 4/5 3/5 4/5 4/5
Sex 3/5 4/5 4/5 3/5
Sleeps Cool 3/5 4/5 4/5 3/5
Pressure Relief 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5
Off-Gassing 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Ease of Movement 3/5 4/5 4/5 3/5
Edge Support 2/5 3/5 4/5 3/5

In-Depth Pricing

The cost of a mattress is determined by a number of things. Smaller sizes, for example, are typically hundreds – if not thousands – of dollars less expensive than larger sizes. The quality of the materials used is also crucial.

In a queen size, an all-foam mattress costs between $900 and $1,200, while a hybrid mattress costs between $1,600 and $2,200. Finally, some mattress brands simply charge a higher price than others. This is especially true for brick-and-mortar businesses, which have substantial overhead costs due to the operation of stores and the hiring of commissioned salespeople. Online retailers typically do not have such high overhead and may sell mattresses for much less.

The tables below show the current prices for each Puffy and Leesa mattress in each possible size.

Puffy

Puffy Mattress Puffy Lux Puffy Royal Puffy Lux Hybrid Puffy Royal Hybrid
Twin $899 $1,449 $1,649 $1,449 $1,649
Twin XL $949 $1,499 $1,749 $1,499 $1,749
Full $1099 $1,599 $2,449 $1,599 $2,499
Queen $1,249 $1,799 $2,699 $1,799 $2,699
King $1,449 $1,999 $2,999 $1,999 $2,999
California King $1,449 $1,999 $2,999 $1,999 $2,999

Leesa

Leesa Original Mattress Leesa Hybrid Mattress Leesa Legend Studio by Leesa
Twin $799 $1,299 $499
Twin XL $849 $1,299 $1,899 $549
Full $999 $1,599 $2,199 $599
Queen $1,099 $1,899 $2,399 $699
King $1,299 $2,099 $2,699 $899
California King $1,299 $2,099 $2,699 $899

The pricing of the Puffy Mattress is comparable to that of the average all-foam mattress. The Puffy Lux, Puffy Lux Hybrid, Puffy Royal, and Puffy Royal Hybrid, on the other hand, are all fairly pricey. If you have a limited shopping budget, the price of these mattresses may be a deterrent.

By comparison, Leesa’s all-foam and hybrid versions are comparable to, if not lower than, industry averages for respective mattress categories. The Leesa Hybrid and Legend, on the other hand, are still quite pricey.

Trial, Warranty, and Delivery

Shipping

Customers in the contiguous United States can get free ground shipping from Puffy. Residents of Alaska and Hawaii must pay an extra delivery fee. This is rather common among mattress-in-a-box businesses. Leesa, on the other hand, offers free ground shipment to every state in the United States. If you live in Alaska or Hawaii, you can save a lot of money by ordering from Leesa. Puffy’s delivery are limited to the United States, while Leesa’s are available in Canada, the United Kingdom, and Germany.

All Puffy and Leesa mattresses will be compressed, vacuum-sealed, and packed in a small box for normal delivery. You won’t have to sign for the delivery or be home when the mattress comes because it will be delivered to your doorstep. Carry the box to the room where the mattress will be used, unbox it, and cut away the plastic using a knife. The mattress will begin to expand right once, but it will take at least 24 hours to fully recover its shape.

For a set cost of $150, Leesa also offers White Glove delivery in specified areas. This service includes a delivery date, mattress assembly in your house, and (if desired) removal of your old mattress and/or box spring. For White Glove delivery, mattresses are not compressed. Puffy does not provide in-home assembly or removal of old mattresses or box springs with any orders.

Returns

Because most internet mattress firms do not have physical stores where you may try out their products, many offer 90-day or longer sleep trials. You should be able to return the mattress for a full refund in most circumstances. Before making a financial commitment to a mattress, sleep trials are required to truly understand how it feels and performs.

Puffy’s sleep experiment lasts for 101 nights after delivery. Puffy asks that you try out the mattress for at least 14 nights before returning or exchanging it, but suggests that you sleep on it for at least 30 nights to thoroughly break it in. Puffy will give a full refund (excluding shipping fees for Alaska and Hawaii) and send couriers to your home to collect the mattress and transfer it for donation or recycling if it is returned. The Puffy sleep trial can be used up to two times per household.

Leesa’s sleep trial will last 100 nights. Although there is no required break-in period with this trial, Leesa, like Puffy, recommends that you try the mattress for at least 30 nights before demanding a return. For consumers in the contiguous United States, Leesa will provide a complete refund and send couriers to pick up the mattress from their home. If you live in Alaska or Hawaii, you’ll have to pay a $100 return fee, but couriers will still come to your house to pick up the mattress for free. Leesa tries to donate all returned mattresses, however if that isn’t possible, they will be recycled.

Warranties

A warranty is an agreement between a product’s maker and its customers that indicates the former is responsible for product repairs or replacements if the latter is defective. The vast majority of mattresses on the market today come with a warranty of at least 10 years.

Puffy is one of the few mattress companies that offers a lifetime warranty that is not prorated. If your mattress develops a problem and needs to be repaired or replaced, you won’t have to pay anything; if the guarantee is lifetime, it covers the mattress for as long as you keep it. Sagging or body impressions in the surface measuring 1.5 inches or deeper, as well as manufacturing problems in the mattress cover, are covered under this warranty.

Leesa’s warranty is a little shorter – totaling 10 years – but it is likewise non-prorated. You won’t have to pay anything to have the mattress fixed or replaced if it develops a flaw during the first ten years, other from modest shipping and transportation expenses. Sagging and body impressions of 1 inch or more, physical flaws that cause materials to decay prematurely, and manufacturing issues with the cover are all covered by this warranty.

Mattress warranties are non-transferable, which means that only the original purchaser is covered. You won’t get guarantee protection if you buy or obtain the mattress from the original purchaser, so always buy mattresses directly from companies or authorized sellers.

Who Should Pick Leesa:

  • Larger persons- While larger people may have trouble “bottoming out” on the Puffy, the Leesa should not be an issue. Heavy persons should not push through the mattress and hit the firm support layers because it has more layers and should be a more supportive mattress.
  • Back or stomach sleepers- While I found both mattresses to be firm, the Leesa is unquestionably the more supportive mattress. Back sleepers shouldn’t sink too far into the mattress, and stomach sleepers who are average or light should find enough support on the Leesa.
  • Those who desire a balanced foam feel- The Leesa is a better alternative for those who prefer a soft foam sensation but don’t want to get caught in their mattress. People shouldn’t have any trouble moving around because the mattress is both pressure reducing and responsive.

Who Should Pick Puffy:

  • Side sleepers who are light or medium-weight—As long as folks aren’t too hefty, the Puffy should be a better suit for side sleeping. Because sleepers burrow into the Puffy’s soft memory foam, they should experience superior pressure relief.
  • Those who enjoy a classic memory foam feel- If you prefer memory foam’s gradual, sinking feel, this mattress is for you. It has a quicksand feel to it, so if folks like that and prefer to sleep in their mattresses, the Puffy should be a good fit.

Overall

People shouldn’t have a hard time choosing between the Leesa and Puffy mattresses if they consider this information. For bigger persons, as well as back and stomach sleepers, the Leesa should be a superior option. On the Leesa, those who want to sleep on top of their mattress will be at ease. The Puffy is likely to be preferred by side sleepers who like to sink into their mattress.

If you have any specific questions or comments about the Leesa or the Puffy, please leave them in the comments area below!

Rate this post