Puffy vs. Tuft And Needle Mattress Comparison: Which Is Best? Update 07/2024

Although there is a large selection of all-foam mattresses available, many customers limit their search to Puffy and Tuft & Needle models. These two companies have received high praise, and their mattresses, particularly their flagship models, the Puffy and the T&N Mattress, contain some of the best features found in all-foam mattresses.

Choosing between these two solutions, on the other hand, might be challenging because each is more or less ideal for various sleepers based on their weight, favorite sleep position, and other considerations.

Tuft & Needle is one of the original “mattress in a box” direct-to-consumer mattress manufacturers. Aside from the T&N mattress, they also have the T&N Mint foam mattress and the T&N Hybrid, which has a pocketed coil support core.

Puffy, on the other hand, has only lately entered the market with their name-brand flagship mattress. In addition to the Puffy Mattress, the business now sells the Puffy Lux and the Puffy Royal, both of which are all-foam mattresses. The Lux Hybrid and Royal Hybrid, which have the same comfort and transitional layers as their all-foam equivalents but pocketed coils in their support cores, were recently released by the business.

While the T&N and Puffy mattresses both have an all-foam composition and a few other features in common, they have significant distinctions. We’ll compare and contrast both brands and mattresses to help you figure out which is best for you.

Puffy Mattress vs Tuft & Needle Synopsis

We appreciate that everyone’s time is valuable, thus we accept that not everyone will want to read the entire post. If that’s the case, consider the following key distinctions between these two beds.

  • Feel – Both of these bed-in-a-box mattresses have a neutral-foam feel to them; however, thanks to its patented top layer, the Puffy mattress has a little bit of a memory foam feel to it.
  • Sleeper Type – We believe Puffy is the somewhat superior option if you spend a lot of time on your side.
  • Tuft & Needle is significantly less expensive than Puffy. Tuft & Needle is the place to go if you’re on a budget.
  • Special Cover — The Puffy mattress’s removable cover is stain-resistant and machine washable.

Those, in our opinion, are the most important choice points. However, there’s always more to think about. Continue reading to find out more.

Honest Puffy vs Tuft and Needle Video Review

[youtube url=”https://youtu.be/HCKNiJU7bD4″ width=”600″ height=”400″ responsive=”yes” autoplay=”no” mute=”no”]

Tuft & Needle vs Puffy: Similarities and Differences

Let’s take a short look at the primary similarities and differences between these two beds before I go into the details. For further information, I recommend reading my full Tuft & Needle mattress review as well as my comprehensive Puffy mattress review.

Main Similarities

  • Both the Tuft & Needle and the Puffy are made entirely of foam. They lack pocketed coil systems and instead rely on high-density polyurethane (poly) foam for support.
  • These mattresses are both bed-in-a-box models. This means they’ll arrive compacted in a box at your house and will need a few hours to decompress before you can sleep on them.
  • Both of these foam beds should be ideal for back sleepers. Both mattresses provide gentle hip support, allowing these sleepers to preserve their spines in a neutral position.
  • Both of these mattresses are unlikely to provide enough edge support or durability for heavier sleepers (above 250 pounds). If you’re a heavier sleeper, our best mattress for heavy people list will help you locate some products that are more suited to your needs.

Main Differences

  • Because of its memory foam structure, the Puffy mattress is softer than the Tuft & Needle.
  • The Puffy mattress is more body-contouring and sinkage than the Tuft & Needle mattress, but the Tuft & Needle is more responsive.
  • The Tuft & Needle mattress is cooler than the Puffy.
  • The Puffy mattress is more pricey than the Tuft & Needle mattress.

Which is Better for You?

So, what do those resemblances and distinctions imply for you? It all relies on your sleeping habits! Check out the list below to see which mattress I’d recommend for your specific needs.

  • Both of these beds could work for you if you sleep on your back. If you want more body-contouring, go for the Puffy, and if you want a firmer feel, go for the Tuft & Needle.
  • If you like a softer mattress, Puffy is the way to go. However, if you want a super-plush sensation, one of our finest soft mattresses would be a better choice.
  • Puffy is a great option if you sleep with a spouse. On the Puffy, a snoring bedmate won’t bother you as much.
  • If you sleep on your stomach and back, the responsive Tuft & Needle mattress is the perfect option for you.
  • If you sleep on your stomach, neither of these mattresses will provide enough support. Instead, I’d recommend one of our top mattresses for stomach sleepers.
  • If you sleep hot, the Tuft & Needle mattress is the better option for you.

Sizing and Weight Options

Choosing the right bed size for you is an important element of purchasing a new mattress. Most providers have a comparable selection of mattress sizes. Despite this, many do not provide more odd sizes (such as king-size variations outside of California), and just a few do offer split sizes. This may have a major impact on your decision, depending on the proportions you require.

While less important than size, height and weight are also important variables. Beds with a higher profile are often more expensive, but they may be better suited to your needs. This is especially true for people who weigh more than 230 pounds and are prone to sinking too far into low-profile beds.

When it comes to setting up or moving your bed, the weight of your mattress is crucial, as particularly heavy mattresses might be difficult to move. When paired with a sleeper’s body weight, bulky mattresses may surpass bed frame weight ratings.


Puffy Mattress

  • Height: 10″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Puffy Lux

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Puffy Royal

  • Height: 14″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Puffy Lux Hybrid

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Puffy Royal Hybrid

  • Height: 14″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Tuft & Needle

T&N Original Mattress

  • Height: 10″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Mint Mattress

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Tuft & Needle Hybrid

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

When it comes to buying a new mattress, determining what size of bed is appropriate for you is critical. The majority of businesses have a similar selection of mattress sizes. Nonetheless, many do not offer more odd sizes (such as king size variants outside of California) and just a few do offer split sizes. This may have a considerable impact on your decision depending on the proportions you require.

While less important than size, height and weight are nevertheless important factors to consider. Higher-profile beds are more expensive, but they may be better suited to your requirements. This is especially true for people who weigh more than 230 pounds and are prone to sinking too deeply into low-profile beds.

When it comes to setting up or moving your bed, the weight of the mattress is the most important factor to consider. Very heavy mattresses are difficult to carry. When paired with a sleeper’s body weight, bulky mattresses may outweigh bed frame weight ratings.

Construction and Materials Comparison

Even though the beds appear to be very similar on the surface, comparing how mattresses are produced is a crucial step. Despite the fact that both the Puffy Original and the T&N Original are all-foam mattresses, the types of foams utilized, the thickness of individual layers, and their overall architecture differ in key ways.

When it comes to mattress construction, there are two primary factors to consider. The first is the effect that specific design choices have on how a bed feels while you sleep in it. An all-foam bed with low-density memory foam in its comfort system, for example, will feel very different from a bed with a high-density polyfoam comfort layer.

Second, the architecture of a bed, as well as the quality of its materials, have a substantial impact on how it performs in a range of key areas, including durability, edge support, and temperature neutrality. The first step in understanding how well a bed operates is to understand its construction.


Puffy has created a reputation for itself by providing an all-foam mattress that provides excellent pressure relief while still providing full-body support. This is enabled by its overall design, but it is also this feature that makes it less suitable for some sleepers.

The Puffy has the same height as the T&N Original at 10 inches, but it is slightly thinner than many competitors. It has a 100 percent polyester cover that is soft, elastic, and stain-resistant. (You can even unzip the cover for a more thorough cleaning.)

The comfort system of a bed affects how it feels, and the Puffy’s two comfort layers are responsible for the Puffy’s resilient pressure alleviation. The first is a 2-inch layer of low-density memory foam that is extra-soft and cradles the body to prevent pressure spots. This layer is also gel-infused, which is supposed to help with temperature neutrality for a cooler night’s sleep.

After that, there’s a 2-inch layer of temperature-resistant polyfoam on the Puffy. This layer gives the sleep surface of the bed a little more responsiveness than memory foam alone would. The polyfoam also serves as a transition layer, keeping sleepers from sinking too deeply into the hard support core.

The 6 inch high support core is comprised of high-density polyfoam. Most all-foam beds have this, and high-density polyfoam provides good stability and support for many sleepers. Edge support and durability are potential concerns since it lacks the horizontal strength of innerspring and pocketed coil cores.

The company also provides the all-foam Puffy Lux and Puffy Royal models in addition to the Puffy. Due to their greater comfort and support layers, these are thicker than the Puffy — 12 inches and 14 inches, respectively.

Due to a specific polyfoam transitional layer, the Puffy Lux provides better support. The support core and memory foam layer are both an inch thicker, resulting in a more plush-feeling sleep surface and a more durable overall construction. When compared to the Puffy, the Lux has a thicker support core that provides superior edge support.

The Puffy Royal is the company’s most costly all-foam type, featuring an extra-thick profile and even more comfort and support layers to match its greater price. This 5.5-inch premium mattress features gel memory foam, conventional memory foam, and temperature-resistant polyfoam in its comfort system. These layers work together to give superior temperature regulation and support than the Puffy and Lux versions. They’re followed by a 1.5-inch convoluted memory foam transitional layer and a 7-inch high-density polyfoam support core.

The Puffy Lux and Puffy Royal are now available with a hybrid structure that replaces the polyfoam support core with a sturdy bed of coils. These beds’ hybrid versions provide more bounce, support, and breathability in exchange for less motion isolation.

Tuft & Needle

The T&N Original was created with the goal of providing good performance at an affordable price, and its design reflects this philosophy. The bed is the same thickness as the Puffy, at 10 inches, but the general construction of the two beds differs significantly.

To begin, the T&N Original’s cover is made of a stretchy polyester and polyamide blend. Both are man-made fabrics, but they have different properties: polyester is stain-resistant and less prone to pilling than polyamide. Polyamide, on the other hand, is exceptionally pleasant to the touch and contains stronger, more flexible fibers. The two fabrics work together to drain away sweat (thanks to the polyester) and allow for easy breathing while remaining soft and comfortable. Unlike the Puffy, the T&N Original has an incorporated cover that cannot be removed for cleaning. The cover of the Mint has an extra layer of antibacterial protection.

A single 3-inch-thick comfort layer is featured on the T&N Original. It’s made of low-density polyfoam, which is softer and more pressure-relieving than memory foam yet slightly springier and more resilient. To offset the tendency of synthetic foam to retain heat, the T&N Original’s comfort system includes gel and graphite infusions, both of which are thought to improve temperature neutrality and promote greater ventilation.

The T&N Original is built on a seven-inch core of high-density polyfoam that is both stable and supportive. The T&N Original’s core, like the majority of all-foam beds, does not provide the same edge support or overall durability as a hybrid model. However, it is expected to please the majority of sleepers while maintaining the low cost of the T&N Original.

Tuft & Needle also provides the T&N Mint and the T&N Hybrid in addition to the T&N Original.

The all-foam T&N Mint expands on the overall design of the T&N Original, but with a transitional layer of gel-infused polyfoam, it adds an extra 2 inches of height. This distinction makes the Mint more supportive and durable than the T&N Original. However, their performance is nearly identical, as the T&N Original and the Mint have very little in common.

The hybrid model from Tuft & Needle, on the other hand, is quite different from the T&N Original and the Mint. It has three layers of comfort: two inches of graphite and gel-infused memory foam, one inch of springy microcoils, and another inch of adaptive polyfoam. Instead of high-density polyfoam, it has a 6-inch pocketed steel coil support core and a final 1-inch layer of high-density polyfoam for overall stability.

The Hybrid is more responsive and supportive than the T&N Original or Mint, but it provides less pressure relief than the all-foam choices.

Average Customer Ratings

Reading verified user reviews can be an excellent method to learn how a mattress performs in real-world situations. However, their utility is limited, and they should only be used as part of your overall research before deciding on the ideal bed for you.

Customer reviews can be found on the company’s own website, which is one of the finest locations to look. It’s also worth looking at reviews on Amazon if a manufacturer sells there. Official sites may or may not curate the reviews available for customers to read, whereas Amazon posts all reviews.

When reading bad reviews, keep two things in mind: how well the firm responded to the reviewer’s concerns, and whether the issues they raise are relevant to your needs. Positive reviews praising a bed’s soft, cushiony pressure alleviation may not be a good indicator if you’re searching for a firm bed with exceptional ease of motion.


Model Average Rating
Puffy Mattress 5/5
Puffy Lux 5/5
Puffy Royal 5/5
Puffy Lux Hybrid
Puffy Royal Hybrid

Tuft & Needle

Model Average Rating
T&N Original Mattress 4.6/5
Mint Mattress 4.6/5
Tuft & Needle Hybrid 4.6/5

In-Depth Ratings

Each mattress is graded in eight different categories during our testing process. When it comes to choosing a mattress, each sleeper has different goals and needs, and these categories help our readers figure out which bed is best for them.

Puffy and Tuft & Needle scored differently in our tests, despite their commonalities. Overall, the Puffy scored lower than the T&N Original, although it outperformed it in a few key areas. This pattern was carried over onto their other mattress lines.


All mattresses are intended to last a certain amount of time before needing to be changed. Some beds, on the other hand, will begin to show their age significantly sooner than others. For example, less lasting all-foam beds may feel softer after a few years than they did when first purchased. The durability of a product is usually determined by a mix of what we know about its construction and the quality of the materials employed, as well as verifiable owner reports.

Motion Isolation

Few couples prefer to sleep on a mattress where they can feel their sleeping companion roll over, change positions, or get out of bed. This category is based on how well a bed suppresses and isolates movement, which is critical for couples but less so for singles. Because of their high point elasticity, all-foam mattresses tend to do well in this category.


The suitability of a mattress for sex, like the previous category, may or may not be a significant issue. We provide an appropriateness rating to mattresses based on a variety of variables, including motion isolation, ease of mobility, edge support, and bounciness and responsiveness. Models with greater bounce and lower point elasticity tend to perform better here than all-foam beds.

Temperature Neutrality

Mattresses can trap heat, resulting in an uncomfortable, hot, and clammy night’s sleep. Those that are temperature-neutral, on the other hand, allow for proper airflow and a more comfortable night in bed. Due to their robust support core and the restricted ventilation associated with most synthetic foams, all-foam beds can score poorly here. Manufacturers frequently address this by employing special foams (such as gel foams or foams infused with other materials) that are supposed to be more temperature tolerant.

Pressure Relief

This category assesses how well a mattress prevents pressure points and provides a pressure-free cradle to avoid stiffness or soreness the following day. Mattresses of any firmness or design can perform well in this category, although all-foam mattresses are recognized to have some of the greatest results. Most individuals need pressure relief, and high-scoring mattresses may be among the most appealing to those suffering from chronic discomfort or stiffness.


A new mattress smells like a new car: distinct, fleeting, and the consequence of substances formed during the manufacturing process. These take the form of volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which are largely safe but can have a strong odor in all-foam beds. In most circumstances, VOCs decay and disappear fast. This category assesses a mattress’s initial odor strength as well as how rapidly it dissipates.

Ease of Movement

Moving about on a mattress’s surface can feel effortless or like you’re attempting to move through water, depending on its composition. Many sleepers prefer one over the other, so it’s often a matter of personal preference. However, for those with mobility issues, as well as making a bed more sex-friendly, flexibility of movement is critical. In general, more conforming beds score lower than more bouncy, responsive versions in this category.

Edge Support

The majority of beds are less supporting near the edges than they are in the center. This category assesses how well people feel supported when sleeping on the edge of the bed, as well as if the bed dips noticeably when sitting on the edge. Couples often choose a bed with adequate edge support since it allows them to use the entire sleeping area of the mattress. This area may be of interest to people who have mobility issues, particularly those who have difficulty getting into or out of bed.


Puffy Mattress Puffy Lux Puffy Royal Puffy Lux Hybrid Puffy Royal Hybrid
Firmness Medium (5) Medium (5) Medium (5) Medium (5) Medium (5)
Durability 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Motion Isolation 5/5 5/5 5/5 4/5 4/5
Sex 2/5 2/5 2/5 3/5 3/5
Sleeps Cool 2/5 2/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Pressure Relief 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5
Off-Gassing 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Ease of Movement 2/5 3/5 2/5 3/5 3/5
Edge Support 3/5 3/5 2/5 3/5 3/5

Tuft & Needle

T&N Original Mattress Mint Mattress Tuft & Needle Hybrid
Firmness Medium Firm (6) Medium Firm (6) Medium (5)
Durability 3/5 4/5 3/5
Motion Isolation 3/5 4/5 3/5
Sex 3/5 3/5 4/5
Sleeps Cool 3/5 4/5 4/5
Pressure Relief 4/5 4/5 3/5
Off-Gassing 3/5 3/5 4/5
Ease of Movement 4/5 3/5 4/5
Edge Support 2/5 3/5 4/5

In-Depth Pricing

The majority of consumers shopping for a new mattress place a high value on price. While it’s easy to believe that a more expensive bed will outperform a less expensive opponent, this is frequently not the case. Because there are so many excellent beds available at low prices, it’s important to look at how a mattress performs across a range of criteria rather than depending solely on its price tag.

The cost of a mattress is influenced by a variety of things. The first and most essential consideration is the bed’s construction: all-foam beds, for example, are less expensive than hybrid ones with pocketed coils, while real latex is more expensive than synthetic foams. The complexity of the bed’s design, as well as the quality of the materials used, play a role. Thicker beds are likewise more expensive because they are constructed of more material.

However, factors that have nothing to do with a mattress’s quality or function can impact its price. Because they eliminate the costs of brick-and-mortar stores, direct-to-consumer mattress firms, for example, have lower prices than typical showroom companies. Companies that spend a lot of money on advertising will pass that expense on to their customers.

It is possible to get a quality mattress in any price range, but it is critical to do your homework before making a purchase.


Puffy Mattress Puffy Lux Puffy Royal Puffy Lux Hybrid Puffy Royal Hybrid
Twin $899 $1,449 $1,649 $1,449 $1,649
Twin XL $949 $1,499 $1,749 $1,499 $1,749
Full $1099 $1,599 $2,449 $1,599 $2,499
Queen $1,249 $1,799 $2,699 $1,799 $2,699
King $1,449 $1,999 $2,999 $1,999 $2,999
California King $1,449 $1,999 $2,999 $1,999 $2,999

Tuft & Needle

T&N Original Mattress Mint Mattress Tuft & Needle Hybrid
Twin $645 $745 $995
Twin XL $695 $845 $1,095
Full $795 $995 $1,395
Queen $895 $1,195 $1,695
King $1,095 $1,395 $1,895
California King $1,095 $1,395 $1,895

While both Puffy and Tuft & Needle sell both low-cost and high-end mattresses, their pricing techniques are vastly different. When comparing their flagship mattresses, it’s clear that the T&N Original is less expensive than the flagship Puffy. The trend continues with their deluxe options: Tuft & Needle’s Mint mattress is only marginally more expensive than the T&N Original, while Puffy’s Lux/Lux Hybrid and Royal/Royal Hybrid mattresses are priced as luxury mattresses.

Given that pocketed coils are more expensive than foam support cores, the T&N Hybrid is an exception. Even though it’s more expensive than the company’s all-foam choices, it’s still less expensive than many hybrid competitors.

For many consumers, the T&N Original will be more enticing than the Puffy because of its lower price. It’s still crucial, though, to make sure you get the correct mattress for your needs. If both are within your price range, one may be a better fit for you than the other, regardless of price.

Trial, Warranty, and Delivery


Puffy Mattresses are available in the United States and Canada. Those in the 48 contiguous states and Canada receive free shipping, while customers in Hawaii and Alaska must pay a $150 flat cost. (When returning a mattress, this cost is non-refundable.) All shipments are handled by FedEx, and you will be given a tracking number once your mattress has been delivered. Your new Puffy mattress should arrive within two to five business days after you place your order.

Tuft & Needle ships across the United States, but not to Canada. Customers in the 48 contiguous states get free shipping, while those in Hawaii and Alaska must pay a cost that varies from $120 to $200 depending on their location. FedEx Ground is the company’s shipping service, and it provides clients with tracking information. (Most Tuft & Needle mattresses are delivered in three to seven business days.) In some zip codes in New York City, Chicago, Phoenix, Los Angeles, San Francisco, and Seattle, same-day delivery is offered for $50. These orders must be placed before 3:45 p.m. local time to be delivered between 4:30 and 9:30 p.m.

White Glove Delivery

Some mattress firms provide White Glove delivery, which entails mattress experts visiting your home to set up your new mattress and, if necessary, remove your old one.

While Puffy does not offer White Glove delivery or the removal of old mattresses, Tuft & Needle does for consumers in the United States. The company will send a team to guarantee your new mattress is put up precisely for a non-refundable $150 fee, and will remove your old mattress for recycling or disposal if requested.

Sleep Trial & Returns

The majority of direct-to-consumer mattress providers provide sleep trials to guarantee that customers are comfortable purchasing a mattress they have never tried. These allow you to sleep on your new mattress before deciding whether or not to keep it, providing a more accurate picture of how it performs than a standard showroom experience. Some companies require a “break-in period” before accepting returns because it can take several weeks to acclimate to a new mattress.

Puffy offers a 101-night sleep trial with a 14-night break-in period, although clients are encouraged to wait 30 days before making a choice. Customers can return the mattress for a complete refund, excluding any shipping fees, after two weeks. (Whenever feasible, returned mattresses are donated.) The sleep trial is only valid for orders purchased on the Puffy website, and refunds are restricted to two per family per year.

Tuft & Needle offers a 100-night sleep trial that does not require any initial break-in time. Returning a mattress results in a complete refund, minus any shipping or White Glove delivery expenses. Those who are satisfied with the company but not with their new mattress have the option of exchanging it for a different model rather than receiving a refund, albeit they will be responsible for any price difference. Customers are encouraged to donate or recycle their returned mattresses, although Tuft & Needle will arrange for pickup if necessary. Each family is only allowed to file one return per year.


The majority of mattresses come with a manufacturer’s warranty. These typically address comparable issues, albeit the duration and terms vary by company.

All Puffy mattresses come with a lifetime, non-prorated warranty. This includes obvious impressions or foam sagging of more than 1.5 inches, as well as flaws or manufacturing errors in the mattress cover or zipper. Personal preference changes or the development of allergies or sensitivities are not covered, nor is normal wear and tear or owner damage. The guarantee is void if the mattress is sold or given away, and it is also void if the mattress is incorrectly supported. Puffy will replace your mattress with the most identical current model in the same size if it develops one of the listed faults.

Tuft & Needle’s mattress warranty is non-prorated and lasts ten years. Manufacturing problems and physical flaws in the mattress foam or cover are covered, as are lingering indentations 0.75 inches or deeper. Damage caused by the owner, normal wear and tear, and indentations deeper than 0.75 inches are not covered. If your mattress is not supported according to Tuft & Needle’s recommendations, the guarantee is void. Tuft & Needle will repair or replace your mattress if it develops any of the mentioned faults within ten years of purchase, at their discretion.

Puffy vs Tuft & Needle Feel Comparison

Next, let’s talk about how each of these beds actually feels. Below, I’ll go into the firmness, pressure relief, and bounce of each of these mattresses in further depth.

Keep in mind that the feel of a mattress will vary based on your body weight and preferred sleeping position. I’m 5′ 9″ and weigh about 125 pounds, and I prefer to sleep on my side.

Tuft & Needle

To begin, I’ll discuss the Tuft & Needle mattress. The firmness of this mattress surprised me. On the firmness scale, I awarded it a 7 out of 10, which is firm compared to the industry standard of 6.5 out of 10.

The Tuft & Needle’s substantial support makes this mattress ideal for back sleepers. It should provide them with some much-needed pressure alleviation and comfort. I particularly like this mattress for people who have sciatica; it should provide the support they require in the lower back to help them sleep better.

For a firm mattress, the Tuft & Needle is springy and responsive. It’s ideal for back and side sleepers who require mobility to change positions during the night. Unfortunately, the Tuft & Needle’s great bounce means it doesn’t isolate motion as well as most all-foam mattresses. Couples who are concerned about being disturbed by a restless companion can consider the Puffy.

For stringent side sleepers, the Tuft & Needle is a little too firm. These people will most likely like the Puffy, albeit it may be a little too firm for side sleepers who prefer a highly soft sensation.

For stomach sleepers, the Tuft & Needle is too soft. These sleepers like firmer mattresses with coil support, so I doubt they’ll be satisfied on the Puffy.


Let’s go on to the Puffy now. The Puffy is a medium-firm mattress that measures 6.5 out of 10 on the firmness scale, which is the industry norm. Because medium firm is the most popular mattress firmness, most people should be OK on the Puffy.

I think the Puffy is a better match for side sleepers than the Tuft & Needle because it has a little more body-contouring than the Tuft & Needle. Its memory foam comfort layer should relieve strain on their hips and shoulders, preventing stiffness and soreness in those areas. The Puffy might be a little too firm for you if you’re a side sleeper looking for a lot of deep sinkage to really protect your pressure points. To discover a softer choice, I’d look through our overview of the best mattresses for side sleepers.

The Puffy, like the Tuft & Needle, is ideal for back sleepers. It offers a good blend of pressure alleviation and support, as well as keeping the hips and shoulders in line. This will assist people who sleep on their backs in avoiding pain and stiffness.

Because the Puffy is less sensitive, combination sleepers may prefer the Tuft & Needle. You might prefer the Puffy if you’re a combination sleeper looking for a softer feel. It has greater sinkage than the Tuft & Needle, but I was still able to move around freely.

The Puffy is likely to be preferred by couples over the Tuft & Needle. Thanks to its gel memory foam layer, this mattress isolates motion a little better. On the Puffy mattress, a snoring partner shouldn’t bother you too much.

The Puffy mattress, like the Tuft & Needle, is a little too soft for stomach sleepers. One of our top innerspring mattresses might be a better fit for these people.

Tuft & Needle vs Puffy: Best Qualities

So, what kind of mattress should you get? I can’t make your decision for you, but I can give you some final considerations to consider.

Tuft & Needle Best Features

  • Back This mattress should be great for sleepers and sciatica patients! It’s incredibly supportive, and it’ll keep their spines in a neutral position.
  • The Tuft & Needle is an excellent value mattress that made our list of the Best Mattresses Under $1,000.
  • The Tuft & Needle sleeps cool, so heat sleepers will appreciate this mattress.
  • To discover more about this bed, I recommend reading our entire Tuft & Needle mattress review!

Puffy Best Features

  • This bed will be ideal for back sleepers. It’s comfortable and supportive, particularly in the lower back.
  • The Puffy, which sleeps significantly cooler than regular memory foam mattresses, will appeal to memory foam fans who sleep hot.
  • Side sleepers, particularly side and back combo sleepers, will appreciate the Puffy’s ability to relieve pressure aches and pains in the shoulders and hips.
  • Interested? For a more in-depth look at this bed, see the complete Puffy mattress review.

Who Should Pick the Tuft & Needle…

  • Back or stomach sleepers: The Tuft & Needle is the more supportive of the two mattresses. The Tuft & Needle’s comfort layer isn’t as thick. If you sleep mostly on your stomach or back, you should feel less like you’re sinking into the mattress.
  • The Tuft & Needle is the more breathable of these two mattresses, and should provide a cooler night’s sleep for hot sleepers. If a person has trouble sleeping cool, the Tuft & Needle should be their first pick.
  • People who want to sleep on top of their mattresses will appreciate this mattress’s balanced foam feel, which allows them to have part of the foam feel while still being able to move around on the mattress. Overall, the Adaptive Foam is extremely responsive, so sleepers should not feel trapped on this mattress.

Who Should Pick the Puffy…

  • Light- or medium-weight side sleepers should obtain more pressure relief on the Puffy if they aren’t too heavy. Sleepers should feel less pressure on their shoulders and hips thanks to the 4″ of memory foam that allows them to sink into the mattress.
  • Those who enjoy a traditional memory foam feel- The Puffy should suit those who wish to slowly sink into their mattress. It has a quicksand feel to it, so it should make people feel like they’re sleeping in the mattress.


Because the differences between these two mattresses are so great, it shouldn’t be too difficult to choose between them after looking at them closely.

The Tuft & Needle is best for stomach and back sleepers who desire a balanced foam feel, while the Puffy is best for side sleepers and enthusiasts of soft memory foam. Consumers should read this material several times, evaluate their personal sleeping habits, and then make a better informed purchasing decision.

Rate this post