Brooklyn Bedding vs. Tuft And Needle Mattress Comparison: Which Is Best? Update 07/2024

You may have heard of Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft & Needle if you’re looking for a new mattress. They’re both well-known direct sellers of sleep products, such as sheets, pillows, and foundations.

The Signature, Aurora, Spartan, Bloom, Bowery, and Bowery Hybrid are the six primary models in Brooklyn Bedding’s mattress collection. The Original, the Mint, and the Hybrid are all available from Tuft & Needle. Hybrid and all-foam variants are available from both firms.

Both companies provide a variety of firmness options. A wider selection of hardness options are available from Brooklyn Bedding, which include medium soft, medium hard, and firm. Both medium and medium firm are available from Tuft & Needle. People who prefer a mattress that is softer or firmer than normal may choose Brooklyn Bedding’s alternatives over the mid-range firmness options given by both brands.

Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft & Needle mattresses have certain similarities that buyers may notice, but the distinctions between the two brands may eventually play a part in selecting which choice is ideal for you. To help you make an informed choice between Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft & Needle, we’ll cover sizing, construction, materials, performance, price and policies.

Brooklyn Bedding vs. Tuft & Needle: Overview

Understanding the distinctions will allow you to make an informed decision about which is best for you. If you’re trying to decide between Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft & Needle, this article should prove useful.

Key Similarities

  • These two products share a business model (online-only) and both come packaged in a box with simply foam inside.
  • In terms of customer service, both organizations are well-known for their extensive return policies and trial periods.
  • The thickness of both mattresses is the same (10″).

Key Differences

  • It costs $150 more (without any discounts from either company) to buy Brooklyn Bedding, but it is more durable.
  • Brooklyn Bedding provides three firmness options, while Tuft & Needle only has one.
  • Tuft & Needle’s comfort layer is polyfoam, but Brooklyn Bedding’s is made entirely of latex.
  • Overall, the Brooklyn Bedding is more robust and bouncier.

Sizing and Weight Options

There is a lot more to consider than just the type of foundation and sheets you need when it comes to your mattress. Mattresses are also influenced by factors such as how well they fit into your room and how comfortable they are.

The size, height, and weight of a mattress can have a significant impact on a person’s level of comfort. For those who share a bed with a spouse, the size matters a lot because it determines how much room they have to move around. The height of a mattress can affect how easy or difficult it is to get into or out of bed, as well as how supportive it feels. The thicker the model, the more appealing it is to heavier people. Weight of the mattress could effect how secure the mattress feels on its frame, which could be significant for sex.

The size and height of the mattress is also dependent on the amount of room you have to work with. When making a bed, a mattress that is too huge for the room may be difficult to get around. With low ceilings or bunk beds, lower-profile models may be better suited for the room.

The size and weight of the mattress might also influence its comfort level. Many mattresses are designed to be rotated frequently to ensure even wear, and lighter and/or smaller mattresses are generally easier to move around.

Brooklyn Bedding

Brooklyn Signature Hybrid

  • Height: 11″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Custom Sizes

Brooklyn Aurora Hybrid

  • Height: 13.5″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Custom Sizes

Sedona Hybrid

  • Height: 14″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Full XL, Queen, King, Split King, California King

Spartan Hybrid Luxe

  • Height: 13″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split California King

Bloom Hybrid

  • Height: 11″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split California King

Brooklyn Bowery

  • Height: 11″, 14″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Custom Sizes

Brooklyn Bowery Hybrid

  • Height: 10″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Custom Sizes

Tuft & Needle

T&N Original Mattress

  • Height: 10″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Mint Mattress

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Tuft & Needle Hybrid

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

While Tuft & Needle offers only three mattress models, there is more variety in the weight and height of Brooklyn Bedding’s mattresses because there are six variants instead of just three.

It weighs 70 pounds for a queen-size Brooklyn Bowery, compared to 120 pounds for a Brooklyn Bloom queen-size. There are three models from which you can choose, and the Original weighs 72 pounds. Tuft & Needle’s heaviest option is the Hybrid, which weighs 112 pounds. The weight variances across brands and models are due to variations in the materials and construction.

10-inch mattresses are the thinnest offerings from both businesses. Brooklyn Bedding makes an 11-inch model and two 13.5-inch alternatives, while Tuft & Needle makes two 12-inch varieties. The Brooklyn Aurora and the Brooklyn Spartan, which are both the brand’s tallest mattresses, are good options for those who desire a thicker mattress.

Both Brooklyn Bedding and Tuft & Needle provide regular mattress sizes, but Brooklyn Bedding also offers a variety of bespoke sizes. Customers who require a mattress with non-standard dimensions will benefit from this feature.

Construction and Materials Comparison

Some of the most popular models on the market now are hybrid, all-foam, innerspring, and latex mattresses. Natural or synthetic latex can be used in latex models. Hybrid models combine both foams and coils, whereas all-foam models employ foam layers.

Different varieties of foam are available for mattresses, and each has its own advantages and disadvantages. For its close-fitting pressure relief, memory foam is a popular choice. However, it can be slow to return to its original shape, making it more difficult to move on. For this reason, many businesses employ unique manufacturing methods and materials to ensure cooling and breathability of their memory foam. Low-density polyfoam, on the other hand, may degrade more quickly because it retains less heat and responds more quickly to pressure changes.

It’s possible to employ latex foam in all-foam, hybrid, or latex mattresses. Natural latex is extremely durable, cool to the touch, and springy compared to other foams. Polyfoam, on the other hand, is typically more expensive and doesn’t provide the same “hugging” sensation as memory foam or polyfoam.

Hybrid and innerspring types rely on coil layers for structural support. While springs provide a bed with bounce and airflow, as they age, they may begin to creak. Additionally, the bounce of the coil layer may assist to the transfer of motion. Coil systems, on the other hand, tend to distribute the weight of the mattress evenly and increase its longevity.

Brooklyn Bedding

The Brooklyn Signature

Despite its high price, the Signature has a luxury feel and is well worth the money. TitanFlex polyfoam is used in the comfort layer, whereas Energex polyfoam is used in the transition layer… In order to achieve a balance between the responsiveness of latex and the contouring of memory foam, both materials have been designed. To keep the sleeper cool, TitanFlex’s comfort layer is packed with gel.

Additional bounce and airflow is provided by a six-inch layer of pocketed coils. Encased coils reduce motion transfer by moving independently. The coil system is supported by a 1-inch layer of polyfoam.

Cushioning and airflow are provided by the Signature’s quilted cover.

The Brooklyn Aurora

The Aurora is equipped with cutting-edge cooling technology and a hybrid design. A woven cover is the first step in this high-end model. 1.5 inches of polyfoam make up the comfort system’s top layer. A phase-change material is used in both the cover and the top comfort layer to help the sleeper maintain a temperature of 88 degrees. Additionally, a copper infusion in the top comfort layer aids in removing body heat. Two inches of latex-like polyfoam provide further shaping and responsiveness in the second comfort layer.

The transition layer is a 1-inch thick layer of memory foam. This layer serves as a barrier between the comfort and support layers, allowing for a more sculpted fit. Adding a gel swirl to the memory foam enhances the mattress’s ability to keep you cool. The bed is then supported by an 8-inch layer of pocketed coils. There are distinct zones for different thicknesses of coils in the body, which results in greater support for portions of the body where people tend to carry more weight, such as the torso and hips, and a gentler feel for the head and shoulders and legs. In addition to providing a springy feel, pocketed coils reduce motion transfer and keep the mattress cooler by allowing air to circulate around the coils. The compression of the coils is supported by a 1-inch layer of polyfoam beneath them.

The Brooklyn Spartan

Active people and muscle recovery are the focus of the Spartan’s design. In order to increase the quality of the sleeper’s rest and speed up recovery, the cover’s smart fabric is designed to reflect body energy back to it. Polyfoam, which is 1.5 inches thick, is the initial layer of the comfort system. This layer adapts to the shape of the body in order to alleviate pressure. Copper and phase-change material infusions keep the bed surface cold. Two inches of latex-like polyfoam are used in the second layer of comfort, which cradles the body more deeply and responds fast to pressure adjustments.

A 1-inch thick layer of memory foam serves as a barrier between the sleeper and the mattress’s stiffer coil core. Additional temperature control is provided by sprinkling it with gel. Bounce, ventilation, and support are all optimized with an 8-inch pocketed coil core, which also limits motion transmission. Final polyfoam layer of 1-inch supports the coil system.

The Brooklyn Bloom

Brooklyn Bedding’s Bloom is the company’s most organic alternative. For the quilted cover, this latex-wool-cotton hybrid uses 1.25-inch squares of Joma wool. The bed has a buoyant feel thanks to a 3-inch covering of pure Talalay latex. Pressure from the sleeper’s weight can be relieved without the mattress squeezing or adapting to the body. The open cell structure of latex makes it a very breathable material.

The 8-inch coil core also allows air to move reasonably easily, helping to regulate the temperature of the sleeping surface. In order to keep vibrations from transferring between coils, these coils have been encased. Also, they give the mattress a little extra bounce. The springs rest on a 1-inch polyfoam foundation.

The Brooklyn Bowery

The Bowery is Brooklyn Bedding’s sole all-foam mattress choice. The mattress is protected from the elements by a woven cover. 3 inches of Energex polyfoam make up the comfort layer. Memory foam, on the other hand, has been created to be more sensitive than this material. The comfort system and the core are separated by a 2-inch polyfoam transition layer. Finally, the bed is supported by a five-inch layer of polyfoam.

The Brooklyn Bowery Hybrid

The Bowery Hybrid is a low-cost hybrid vehicle. Comfort and pressure relief are provided by the quilted top’s 1 inch of memory foam. Gel is included into the foam to keep the surface cool. Polyfoam is used in the transition layer to keep the sleeper from sinking into the solid coil core. Using six inches of pocketed springs, this coil core provides bounce while preventing motion dispersion. Flowing air helps dissipate heat in this stratum. Lastly, a 1-inch layer of polyfoam serves as a base for the springs to rest on.

Tuft & Needle

The Original and the Mint

The Original and the Mint, both made of foam, by Tuft & Needle, are made of similar materials. Tuft & Needle’s main model is the Original, while the Mint is a high-end alternative.

A micro polyamide and polyester blend is used to make the soft, breathable covers for both mattresses. The fabric of the Mint’s cover also contains an antibacterial protectant. This is followed by a 3-inch layer of T&N Adaptive polyfoam in each model. As the sleeper’s body heat is pulled away from the surface, this material helps keep the sleep surface at a comfortable temperature. To keep things cold, the upper layer of the Mint contains more graphite. The Mint also features a 2-inch transition layer of T&N Adaptive polyfoam for additional cradling and pressure relief.

Both the Original and the Mint are supported by a 7-inch polyfoam core, which ensures the beds’ long-term stability.

The Hybrid

Tuft & Needle’s only mattress with a coil core is the Hybrid. A total of six separate layers make up the structure.

The Hybrid, like the Original and the Mint, has a micro polyamide and polyester cover. This cover is permeable so that the mattress can be kept cool by the passage of air. The cover is cushioned by a 1-inch layer of polyfoam quilted into it. Carbon and graphite are incorporated into this polyfoam to help it wick away heat. T&N’s Adaptive polyfoam, a 2-inch thick layer, cradles the sleeper’s body to alleviate pressure points. Graphite and ceramic gel infusions help to dissipate heat even more effectively.

The coil core is hardly felt by sleepers thanks to two transition layers. An additional 1-inch layer of microcoils provides additional bounce and cradling while not limiting airflow. Adaptive polyfoam, a 1-inch layer, supports the microcoils and separates them from the coil core.

The bed’s support, bounce, breathability, and motion isolation are all improved by a 6-inch layer of pocketed coils. Adding reinforcement to the border of the bed gives it a more solid feel. The springs rest on a 1-inch sheet of polyfoam.

Average Customer Ratings

To get a feel for how a mattress functions for actual people, one of the best ways to learn is to read customer reviews. Seeing what others think of a mattress might comfort you that it’s a good fit for your needs and preferences.

While consumer feedback is valuable, it’s important to keep an eye out for any potential problems. A person’s level of comfort can differ from another person’s, therefore what they find pleasant may not be as comfortable for you. The subjective nature of mattress reviews makes it possible for them to be at odds with one another. You may have to read the reviews carefully to determine which reviews are most relevant to your own circumstances. Finally, there are reviews that are ambiguous. Instead of utilizing general terms like “comfortable” or “uncomfortable,” we recommend that you look for evaluations that provide specific criticism.

Brooklyn Bedding

Model Average Rating
Brooklyn Signature Hybrid 4.7/5
Brooklyn Aurora Hybrid 4.7/5
Spartan Hybrid Luxe 4.8/5
Bloom Hybrid 4.8/5
Brooklyn Bowery 4.8/5
Brooklyn Bowery Hybrid 4.7/5

Tuft & Needle

Model Average Rating
T&N Original Mattress 4.6/5
Mint Mattress 4.6/5
Tuft & Needle Hybrid 4.6/5

In-Depth Ratings

Every person’s sleeping habits and preferred level of comfort are unique. You must carefully compare your preferences against the model’s qualities while deciding on the ideal mattress for you. A mattress’s sleep experience, comfort, and lifetime may be affected by the following elements. Mattresses can be purchased with ease if you know what features are important to you.

  • A mattress’s longevity and resistance to sagging and degeneration are directly related to its durability. High-quality mattresses are more long-lasting, but they also come at a higher price. Some folks may find this initial investment intimidating. However, long-lasting models may be a superior long-term investment.
  • As a mattress is moved by an individual, some of that movement may be transmitted to other parts of the mattress. Couples, especially those who wake up easily, may find this motion transfer difficult to deal with. For couples, a mattress with high motion isolation may help them sleep better and wake less frequently.
  • Having a mattress that is more than just comfortable for sleeping is preferred by many couples. Sexual activity can also be affected by a mattress’s design. Two of the most important considerations are responsiveness and bounce. Beds with coil cores have a springy feel, but as they wear down, they may emit noise. Some couples choose a traction system that conforms to their body shape.
  • Temperature Control: If you’re prone to overheating while you sleep, this may be an important consideration. Heat retention is more of a problem with some mattress materials than others. Many mattresses use unique features to mitigate the heat-trapping effects of memory foam. Open-cell polyfoam and coils, as well as latex and latex-like materials, allow for better airflow, which aids in the removal of heat.
  • Pressure Relief: Those who suffer from nighttime aches and pains may benefit from a mattress that provides greater pressure relief. Pressure-relieving mattresses distribute the weight of the sleeper more evenly. As a result, this alleviates strain on the hips and shoulders, two locations where it tends to build. Customers may want to keep an eye out for phrases like “contouring” and “conforming” while they’re shopping for a new mattress.
  • It is not uncommon for mattresses to have a lingering smell from the manufacturing process. Compressed mattresses can arrive at your door without having had time to air out. Mattresses that employ synthetic foam are more likely to emit off-gassing aromas, although other materials may also emit a stench. People who are sensitive to odors may prefer a mattress that is less prone to off-gassing, or they may choose to let their new mattress air out in a different room before usage, even though most people don’t mind these odors.
  • Easy of mobility impacts the amount of effort it takes to shift positions or to move over the bed surface. An easy-to-move mattress is ideal for those who have mobility challenges or who toss and turn a lot at night. Movement can be restricted by materials that are sluggish to respond to pressure changes, models that conform closely, and soft comfort layers that allow a lot of sinkage. Mattresses that use a lot of memory foam tend to get lower marks in this category because it conforms so closely and takes so long to restore its original shape. Because latex and coils provide a more responsive feel, mattresses made with these materials often outperform others in their class.
  • Edge support is especially crucial if you want to sit or sleep near the mattress’s edge. The ability to utilize more of the mattress surface is another reason why couples want a mattress with a solid edge. Sleepers who observe a lot of sinkage along the bed’s periphery may decide to relocate closer to the center in order to prevent rolling off. Mattresses with coil support layers, in particular, may have a separate edge reinforcement. Others are able to rely on their solid cores to provide edge support.

Brooklyn Bedding

Brooklyn Signature Hybrid Brooklyn Aurora Hybrid Spartan Hybrid Luxe Bloom Hybrid Brooklyn Bowery Brooklyn Bowery Hybrid
Firmness Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8) Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7) Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7) Medium (5), Firm (7) Medium Firm (6) Medium Firm (6)
Durability 3/5 4/5 4/5 4/5 3/5 3/5
Motion Isolation 4/5 4/5 4/5 3/5 4/5 3/5
Sex 3/5 3/5 3/5 4/5 3/5 3/5
Sleeps Cool 3/5 3/5 3/5 4/5 3/5 3/5
Pressure Relief 4/5 4/5 4/5 3/5 4/5 4/5
Off-Gassing 4/5 3/5 3/5 4/5 3/5 4/5
Ease of Movement 3/5 3/5 3/5 4/5 3/5 4/5
Edge Support 3/5 3/5 3/5 4/5 3/5 3/5

Tuft & Needle

T&N Original Mattress Mint Mattress Tuft & Needle Hybrid
Firmness Medium Firm (6) Medium Firm (6) Medium (5)
Durability 3/5 4/5 3/5
Motion Isolation 3/5 4/5 3/5
Sex 3/5 3/5 4/5
Sleeps Cool 3/5 4/5 4/5
Pressure Relief 4/5 4/5 3/5
Off-Gassing 3/5 3/5 4/5
Ease of Movement 4/5 3/5 4/5
Edge Support 2/5 3/5 4/5

Trial, Warranty, and Delivery


Brooklyn Bedding

Within the contiguous United States, Brooklyn Bedding mattresses are shipped for free. In most cases, mattresses are delivered within 3-4 business days from Phoenix, AZ. Compressed, covered in plastic, and transported via FedEx, each mattress is carefully packaged.

Orders to Alaska, Hawaii, and Canada are subject to shipping charges. For shipments to Alaska and Hawaii, the cost is $125 each mattress, and for exports to Canada, the cost is $250 per mattress.

Tuft & Needle

A majority of Tuft & Needle mattresses are delivered within three to seven business days inside the contiguous US. Shipped by FedEx, mattresses are normally delivered to the customer’s door unattended. To ensure that your mattress arrives on time, you can choose to have your customers sign for the delivery. Compressed in plastic, rolled and placed in a box, each mattress is shipped to customers.

Orders to Alaska and Hawaii normally take between 7 and 10 days to reach their destinations. Typically, the cost of shipping a mattress to these locations is between $150 and $200.

White Glove shipping inside the contiguous United States is available from Tuft & Needle for a one-time price of $150 that is nonrefundable. XPO, a third-party logistics company, provides this service. Upon arrival, a staff will set up the new mattress, remove the old one, and deliver the new one to your home.

Sleep Trial

Brooklyn Bedding

Customers can test their Brooklyn Bedding mattress for a full 120 nights at home. Before a customer can begin a return, they must complete a 30-night break-in period. You can contact Brooklyn Bedding if you are not satisfied with your mattress during the eligible period.

As a company, Brooklyn Bedding is committed to finding a solution, which may involve working with an owner to customize the mattress or assisting a customer in assessing their foundation. If the consumer decides to switch the mattress for a more expensive model, they will be charged for the difference in price.

Brooklyn Bedding welcomes returns for a full refund of the purchase price during the sleep trial if the other alternatives do not work.

This sleep trial is only available once every calendar year to each customer.

Tuft & Needle

In the US, Tuft & Needle offers a 100-night sleep trial to consumers.

In order to return a Tuft & Needle mattress, you must first contact customer service. You can donate it to a local charity with the help of the company. Tuft & Needle will arrange for a third-party service to remove the mattress for free if an appropriate organization cannot be located. When a consumer donates a mattress, Tuft & Needle initiates a reimbursement of the purchase price when the customer submits the receipt. The cost of delivery is not refundable.

Alternatively, customers can call the company and request an alternative model of mattress. If customers choose a more expensive model, they will be charged the difference in price; otherwise, they will be refunded the difference in price. There will be no trial period for the new product.

For Tuft & Needle, each household is limited to one return per year. Sleep trials and return policies for mattresses sold by other sellers may differ.


When purchasing a mattress, the original purchaser is usually covered by some sort of warranty. When you purchase a mattress, the majority of warranty policies are already included in the purchase price.

There are a wide range of warranties in terms of what they cover, how the company handles warranty claims, and what customers can do to void them. It’s a good idea to familiarize yourself with the warranty terms before making a mattress purchase so you know what you’re getting into.

Each warranty is unique, although the majority of them endure for several years or more. Cracks or splits in the foam are among the most common faults covered by the warranty. Mattresses with qualifying defects can be repaired or replaced by most firms, but some companies may charge for this.

To qualify for warranty coverage, customers may be required to follow the mattress’s care instructions. Leaving the mattress compressed for too long, misusing the mattress, abusing the mattress, or otherwise destroying the mattress may void several warranty policies.

Brooklyn Bedding

The initial purchaser of a Brooklyn Bedding mattress is covered by a 10-year warranty. It covers 1 inch or more imprints, sagging, splitting or cracking faults and latex or foam cell structural defects. An inappropriate foundation or misuse of the mattress or exposure to unsanitary circumstances will void the warranty. Damage caused by any of these situations will not be covered by this warranty. The guarantee may be voided if the mattress is compacted for more than 60 days.

Repairs or replacements will be offered if Brooklyn Bedding decides a mattress has a problem which qualifies.

A Brooklyn Bedding warranty claim will not be honored without proof of purchase. There are additional conditions that must be met.

Tuft & Needle

For customers in the United States, Tuft & Needle mattresses are covered by a 10-year limited warranty. Foam faults, such as drooping or indentations over.75 inches deep, and cover defects like unraveling stitching, are covered by this warranty. This means that damaged mattresses can be repaired or replaced by Tuft and Needle, depending on the severity of the problem.

To qualify for this guarantee, you must have purchased the mattress from an authorized distributor. In addition, it excludes mattresses that are used for business purposes, as well as damage caused by incorrect usage, abuse, bad maintenance, or improper foundations.

As evidence of purchase, the customer may be asked to present their receipt. There are additional conditions that must be met.

Rate this post