Casper vs. Amerisleep Mattress Comparison: Which Is Best? Update 08/2022

The Amerisleep vs Casper debate continues. What a great sense of style you have! One of the most popular internet mattresses is Casper’s first model, which pioneered beds-in-a-box. Five distinct mattress alternatives are available from Amerisleep, which caters to all sleepers.

Here, we’ve tested the original Casper mattress against the most popular Amerisleep AS3 mattress. I can’t wait to see how these two titans compare!

Amerisleep vs. Casper Mattress Overview

Even though both the Casper and the Amerisleep AS3 are well-known internet mattresses, they’re best suited to distinct kinds of sleepers than the other. An overview of who could like the Amerisleep and who might prefer the Casper follows.

Who Should Get the Amerisleep?

  • Those who sleep on their sides and need a lot of support.
  • People who seek a wide range of stiffness options In addition to the AS3, the Amerisleep series also includes four more models.
  • People who prefer a mattress that moves more slowly

Who Should Get the Casper?

  • those in search of financial savings
  • People who prefer a more bouncy mattress.
  • Those who sleep on their backs and need extra back support.

Sizing and Weight Options

Simple, down-to-earth considerations can have an impact on your mattress purchase. A mattress’s dimensions, weight, and height are only a few examples.

Making ensuring you and your bed companion, if applicable, have adequate room to spread out and relax is made easier by choosing the proper mattress sizes. The mattress, on the other hand, must be able to fit comfortably in your bedroom.

In addition to ensuring that your fitted sheet fits properly, the height you choose can have an impact on how easy it is to get into and out of bed.

When moving a mattress, the most important consideration is its weight. Even with the assistance of two or three persons, moving a particularly heavy bed can be a challenge. A lighter mattress may be necessary for persons who frequently relocate.

Casper

Casper Original Mattress

  • Height: 11″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Casper Original Hybrid

  • Height: 11″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Casper Wave Hybrid

  • Height: 13″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Casper Element

  • Height: 10″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Casper Nova Hybrid

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Amerisleep

AS1

  • Height: 10″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King

AS2

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King

AS3

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King

AS4

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King

AS5

  • Height: 14″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King

Amerisleep and Casper have a lot in common when it comes to their measurements. Fitted sheets should fit all of the models because the height is similar. Similarly, both firms offer all of their mattresses in all six regular sizes. The following are the main differences:

  • Although Casper consumers can purchase two Twin XL mattresses to serve the same purpose, Amerisleep explicitly offers a Split King alternative.
  • Casper has hybrid and all-foam mattresses, but Amerisleep solely sells all-foam mattresses.
  • Unlike foam mattresses from both companies, Casper’s hybrid mattresses are substantially heavier. Because the innerspring component is heavier than foam, a hybrid mattress is expected to be heavier.

Construction and Materials Comparison

It’s important to know how a mattress is built so that you know what to expect in terms of performance and durability.

Mattresses’ inner construction can be explained using a few basic terms. At the very top of the mattress, the mattress’s comfort system (which might include more than one layer) has the greatest impact on the bed’s feel. The mattress’s ase is located at the bottom of the mattress.

A hybrid mattress comprises a support core constructed of coils, as well as a thick comfort system that can include a variety of materials. All-foam mattresses have a polyfoam support core and a comfort system that can incorporate various materials.

Reviewing the construction of each brand’s mattress reveals that both Casper and Amerisleep exhibit intelligent design.

Casper

In total, Casper provides five mattress options. One is an all-foam product, while the other three are hybrids. Each mattress has a cover composed of a blend of recycled plastics, polyester, up-cycled cotton and rayon as well as spandex, which is the same for all of them. An eco-friendly cover that is both breathable and flexible is made possible by a unique blend of materials.

Casper Original & Casper Hybrid 

According to the company’s name, the Casper Original mattress was the first to be released. An all-foam construction and three internal layers make it a unique product.

  • specialized polyfoam, 1.5 inches thick
  • Memory foam with three zones is 2 inches thick.
  • Base polyfoam of 7 inches thick

Based on the success of Casper Original, the Casper Hybrid is an updated version. Although the mattress’ top three layers (the “comfort system”) are virtually identical, its “support core” differs. The Casper Hybrid mattress includes a total of three layers:

  • Special polyfoam with a 1.5-inch thickness
  • 2 inches of memory foam with three distinct zones
  • a foam encasement of 7 inches around the coils

Two unique foams are combined in the comfort mechanism of both of these mattresses, creating a blend of both contouring and bounce. There is a lot of bounce and edge support in the Casper Hybrid thanks to the innerspring coils and the high density foam encasement around them. The medium (5) firmness rating applies to both the Casper Original and the Casper Hybrid.

Casper Nova Hybrid

A brand-new Casper mattress, the Nova Hybrid features four distinct layers on the inside:

  • airscape polyfoam with a thickness of one inch
  • AirScape polyfoam in a 3-zoned 1.5-inch thickness
  • A two-inch layer of seven-zoned memory foam
  • a foam encasement of 7 inches around the coils

The Casper Nova Hybrid has a medium (5) level of plushness, while yet providing good spinal support because to the many types of foam used in its construction. While still being responsive, the AirScape polyfoam used in this model is extremely breathable. Using zoned foams and memory foam, the Nova Hybrid mattress provides additional support and pressure relief for heavier regions of the body.

Casper Wave Hybrid

Incorporating design advances from Casper’s product development program, the Casper Wave Hybrid is a high-end mattress. It consists of five parts:

  • airscape polyfoam with a thickness of one inch
  • AirScape polyfoam is 1.5 inches thick.
  • 1.5 inches of AirScape foam in three zones.
  • Zoned polyfoam with gel pods tailored to specific areas is 1.5 inches thick.
  • a foam encasement of 7 inches around the coils

Casper’s AirScape polyfoam is used in the top three layers of the Wave Hybrid mattress. Zoned AirScape formulation is used in the third layer to enhance comfort and support to the midsection. A polyfoam mattress with customized gel pods allows the mattress to feel personalized to the weight distribution of each sleeper. Stability, bounce, and edge support are provided by a thick coil layer with a perimeter encasement. The Wave Hybrid’s overall comfort level is medium (5).

Casper Element

This is Casper’s all-foam mattress at an inexpensive price. Casper’s medium firm (6) mattress is the firmest in the company’s line-up. It has a simple two-layer internal design:

  • AirScape polyfoam is 3 inches thick.
  • Base polyfoam is 6.5 inches thick.

An entry-level mattress from Casper is a solid option, even though it lacks some of the advanced features featured in the company’s other mattresses.

Amerisleep

All of Amerisleep’s five mattresses are made of the same materials: all-foam. There is a significant difference in thickness and stiffness between these selections.

All Amerisleep mattresses have a few common components, such as:

  • In order to keep the mattress surface cool, Amerisleep covers are comprised of a breathable blend of cotton and polyester.

Bio-foams: Plant-based oils can be substituted for some of the petrochemicals generally used in foam production by Amerisleep, which produces many of its foams. Consequently, the carbon footprint of the Bio-Pur memory foam and Bio-Core base polyfoam in many other mattresses is smaller. Compared to other types of memory foam, the Bio-Pur foam has a higher density, at 4 pounds per cubic foot (PCF).

It’s known as Surface Modification Technology. This polyfoam, known as HIVE by the business, has five zones across it to better support different parts of the body.

The Amerisleep AS1 mattress is the firmest and features the thinnest total comfort system of all the mattresses. It has two internal layers and a firm (7) texture:

  • Bio-Pur memory foam, 2 inches thick
  • The Bio-Core base polyfoam is 8 inches thick.

For the AS2, we used a medium-firm (6-point firmness) feel with three different layers:

  • Bio-Pur memory foam, 2 inches thick
  • SMT polyfoam in a 3-inch thick layer with five zones
  1. Bio-Core foundation polyfoam is 7 inches in thickness.
  • The AS2’s SMT polyfoam enhances the AS1’s ability to mold to the wearer’s body.

The inside of the AS3 is divided into three sections, each with a medium (5) feel:

  • a layer of Bio-Pur memory foam that is 3 inches thick
  • Polyfoam sandwiched between two layers of 5-zone SMT polyfoam
  • Bio-Core foundation polyfoam is 7 inches in thickness.

Memory foam is thicker than SMT foam in the AS3, offering a softer and more contoured feel to the mattress.

  • In addition to the three layers, the AS4 features a medium soft (4) firmness level.
  • 4-inch-thick memory foam made of Bio-Pur
  • SMT polyfoam with five zones, 1 inch thick
  • Bio-Core foundation polyfoam is 7 inches in thickness.

In terms of motion isolation and deep contouring, the AS4 mattress from Amerisleep features the deepest memory foam layer among the company’s offerings.

  • The AS5 has four layers, but it still has a soft (3) feel:
  • a layer of Bio-Pur memory foam that is 3 inches thick
  • ActiveFlex polyfoam is 2 inches thick.
  • Polyfoam sandwiched between two layers of 5-zone SMT polyfoam
  • Bio-Core foundation polyfoam is 7 inches in thickness.

The ActiveFlex polyfoam used in the AS5 gives it a latex-like texture. Because of this, the AS5 is more responsive than the other Amerisleep models, despite the fact that it is just as cozy.

Bio-Pur memory foam in the top layer of all Amerisleep mattresses provides significant pressure relief and motion isolation. As a result, the base polyfoam creates a strong feel and enhances the comfort system’s overall efficiency.

In-Depth Ratings

An expensive mattress isn’t out of the ordinary; in fact, it’s common for premium mattresses to cost more than cheap ones. A short look at mattress options reveals that the prices vary widely. Mattress prices are influenced by a number of factors, including:

  • How many layers/materials are used and their thickness
  • How many layers there are in a cake
  • Features that are unique to this model (including those for cooling, cleaning, or bodily recovery)
  • Materials with a high degree of specialization (including organic or eco-friendly materials)

In which country did you buy your mattress?

Casper and Amerisleep offer mattresses in a variety of price ranges, so that anybody can find something they like. The following table breaks down the costs of each model according to available sizes. Make sure to keep in mind that these are retail (MSRP) prices, which might be reduced by promotions and discounts.

 

Casper

[table]
  Casper Original Mattress Casper Original Hybrid Casper Wave Hybrid Casper Element Casper Nova Hybrid
Twin $695 $995 $1,595 $249 $1,195
Twin XL $795 $1,095 $2,195 $299 $1,595
Full $995 $1,295 $2,545 $374 $1,945
Queen $1,095 $1,395 $2,695 $449 $2,095
King $1,495 $1,795 $3,295 $574 $2,695
California King $1,495 $1,795 $3,295 $574 $2,695
Split King

[/table]

 

Amerisleep

[table]
  AS1 AS2 AS3 AS4 AS5
Twin $1,049 $1,249 $1,449 $1,649 $1,949
Twin XL $1,099 $1,299 $1,499 $1,699 $1,999
Full $1,249 $1,449 $1,649 $1,849 $2,149
Queen $1,299 $1,499 $1,699 $1,899 $2,199
King $1,599 $1,799 $1,999 $2,199 $2,499
California King $1,599 $1,799 $1,999 $2,199 $2,499
Split King $1,898 $2,298 $2,698 $3,098 $3,698

[/table]

 

Unlike Amerisleep’s AS1 mattress, Casper’s Element and Original mattresses are both less expensive than Amerisleep’s lowest-cost mattress, the AS1. In instance, the Element is the most affordable option for those on a tight budget.

The Casper Wave Hybrid is the most expensive option from the two firms, with a higher price tag than Amerisleep’s AS5 mattress. The Nova Hybrid from Casper is likewise nearly as expensive as the AS5.

For the most part, both firms offer high-quality mattresses at a variety of pricing points, and they both routinely provide coupons or discounts to assist informed customers save even more money during a mattress sale.

In-Depth Pricing

An expensive mattress isn’t out of the ordinary; in fact, it’s common for premium mattresses to cost more than cheap ones. A short look at mattress options reveals that the prices vary widely. Mattress prices are influenced by a number of factors, including:

  • How many layers/materials are used and their thickness
  • How many layers there are in a cake
  • Features that are unique to this model (including those for cooling, cleaning, or bodily recovery)
  • Materials with a high degree of specialization (including organic or eco-friendly materials)

In which country did you buy your mattress?

Casper and Amerisleep offer mattresses in a variety of price ranges, so that anybody can find something they like. The following table breaks down the costs of each model according to available sizes. Make sure to keep in mind that these are retail (MSRP) prices, which might be reduced by promotions and discounts.

Casper

[table]
  Casper Original Mattress Casper Original Hybrid Casper Wave Hybrid Casper Element Casper Nova Hybrid
Twin $695 $995 $1,595 $249 $1,195
Twin XL $795 $1,095 $2,195 $299 $1,595
Full $995 $1,295 $2,545 $374 $1,945
Queen $1,095 $1,395 $2,695 $449 $2,095
King $1,495 $1,795 $3,295 $574 $2,695
California King $1,495 $1,795 $3,295 $574 $2,695
Split King

[/table]

 

Amerisleep

[table]
  AS1 AS2 AS3 AS4 AS5
Twin $1,049 $1,249 $1,449 $1,649 $1,949
Twin XL $1,099 $1,299 $1,499 $1,699 $1,999
Full $1,249 $1,449 $1,649 $1,849 $2,149
Queen $1,299 $1,499 $1,699 $1,899 $2,199
King $1,599 $1,799 $1,999 $2,199 $2,499
California King $1,599 $1,799 $1,999 $2,199 $2,499
Split King $1,898 $2,298 $2,698 $3,098 $3,698

[/table]

 

Unlike Amerisleep’s AS1 mattress, Casper’s Element and Original mattresses are both less expensive than Amerisleep’s lowest-cost mattress, the AS1. In instance, the Element is the most affordable option for those on a tight budget.

The Casper Wave Hybrid is the most expensive option from the two firms, with a higher price tag than Amerisleep’s AS5 mattress. The Nova Hybrid from Casper is likewise nearly as expensive as the AS5.

For the most part, both firms offer high-quality mattresses at a variety of pricing points, and they both routinely provide coupons or discounts to assist informed customers save even more money during a mattress sale.

Trials, Warranty and Delivery

Casper and Amerisleep have good reputations for customer service, and a large part of that comes from how they handle shipping, refunds, and warranties. For those who have never purchased a mattress online before, this information will help ensure that you get the best experience possible.

Shipping

Mattresses-in-a-box are the most common method of delivery for internet beds. In this approach, the mattress is wrapped in plastic, placed in a cardboard box, and delivered to your home by ground shipment. To get the mattress back to its original size, just remove the packaging from the box and place the mattress in your bedroom. The mattress should be lifted and set up by two individuals at the same time.

Delivery services that comprise a team of professionals that come to your home and assemble your mattress may be available from time to time. An old mattress is typically hauled away as part of this White-Glove delivery service.

Casper Shipping Policies

Casper offers free standard shipping to the contiguous 48 states of the United States as well as Canada. Other areas, such as Alaska, Hawaii, and select countries outside the United States, can be shipped to for an additional fee. Deliveries to most locations of the continental United States arrive within five business days, and expedited delivery is available in other areas.

A Casper model of your choosing can be delivered to your home for $149, which also covers removal of your old mattress.

Amerisleep Shipping Policies

In the contiguous United States, Amerisleep offers free FedEx standard shipping. Within 5-7 business days, these shipments are normally delivered. Extra fees are required for delivery to Alaska, Hawaii, and a few additional locations. If you live in one of these areas and would like a shipping quote, please get in touch with Amerisleep directly.

It is only available to customers who purchase a bed foundation from Amerisleep.

Sleep Trial and Returns

A sleep trial is offered by online mattress providers in order to give their consumers an opportunity to test out a mattress. Customers can try the mattress out for a certain period of time and return it for a full refund if they aren’t satisfied with it. Some companies need a break-in period before a refund may be requested because a new mattress can take some time to get acclimated to. When a mattress provider arranges for a free pickup of a mattress that is to be returned, it is common for the consumer to arrange a local donation or, in rare situations, to pay for the return shipping.

Casper Sleep Trial and Return Policy

They provide a 100-night sleep trial with no break-in period for their mattresses. Customers can request a return at any time during the first 100 nights after delivery, and Casper will arrange for the pickup of the mattress. Full refunds are offered if the mattress is returned, but In-Home Delivery and Setup charges cannot be refunded.

Amerisleep Sleep Trial and Return Policy

All of Amerisleep’s mattresses come with a 100-night risk-free trial. Before requesting a refund, you must first complete a 30-night trial period. As a customer of Amerisleep, you can return your mattress and get a complete refund without any additional fees.

Warranty

A guarantee protects you in the event that your mattress has a severe defect that you didn’t know about. In order for customers to understand that flaws are distinct from normal wear and tear, they need to be aware of the difference. Any damage that occurs as a result of misuse or abuse is also not covered by the guarantee. For every warranty, there is an expiration date and a solution (what the company does if a defect occurs).

Casper Mattress Warranty

A ten-year warranty is included with each Casper mattress. It is Casper’s policy to repair or replace your mattress at no cost to you, including any warranty-related shipping costs.

Amerisleep Mattress Warranty

This guarantee from Amerisleep covers flaws in materials and manufacture for 20 years. Amerisleep will repair or replace a faulty mattress for free for the first ten years. Customer must pay 50 percent of the original pricing and delivery costs for a replacement mattress in years 11 through 20.

Rate this post