Puffy vs. Casper Mattress Comparison: Which Is Best? Update 06/2022

The act of comparing mattresses is a crucial part of the mattress-buying process. Every mattress is individually designed to provide a feel that is more comfortable for some people and less pleasant for others. You can get a decent notion of price expectations, shipping alternatives, return policies, and other aspects by comparing different brands and models. We’ll compare Puffy and Casper, two of the most popular “mattress-in-a-box” brands in the United States, in this guide.

Puffy was founded in the year 2017. The Puffy Mattress, the company’s flagship bed, is a 10-inch model featuring a memory foam comfort layer, polyfoam transitional layer, and a high-density polyfoam base. The mattress’ deep contouring and delayed reaction give it the classic memory foam sensation that many people associate with this mattress type. Two more all-foam variants are available from Puffy. The Puffy Lux is 12 inches thick and has an additional foam comfort layer, providing in a more body-conforming and pressure-relieving experience for some sleepers. The Puffy Royal, a 14-inch mattress with three comfort layers and a zoned transitional layer for increased sleeper support, is Puffy’s thickest and most expensive mattress. The three all-foam Puffy variants are regarded medium firm in terms of stiffness (5). The Lux Hybrid and Royal Hybrid, two coil mattresses from Puffy, have the same firmness levels, profiles, comfort and transitional layers, and firmness levels as the all-foam variants with the same names.

Casper is a company that has been around since 2014. The Casper Original is a mixed-foam mattress featuring an open-cell polyfoam comfort layer, a zoned memory foam transitional layer, and a high-density polyfoam base. This mattress has more responsiveness and conforms less than the Puffy Mattress because it has polyfoam on top. The Casper Hybrid is a hybrid version of the Casper Original that replaces the basic polyfoam with a pocketed coil support core. Casper also has two premium hybrid vehicles, the Nova Hybrid and the Wave Hybrid. Casper’s hybrid models, like the original, have zoned transitional layers to provide greater support for your body. The Casper Element, a budget-friendly all-foam bed, is also available from Casper. The firmness of these beds varies from medium (5) to medium hard (6).

We’ll compare the Puffy and Casper mattresses in terms of mattress construction, pricing, performance ratings, and customer policies in our Puffy vs. Casper mattress comparison. Continue reading to find out more.

Casper And Puffy Mattress Overview

Casper and Puffy are two popular internet mattresses that have proven to be of high quality. The original Puffy is an all-foam bed with a balanced foam feel, while the adaptable Casper incorporates a revolutionary Zoned Support system that gives a blend of comfort and support.

Who Should Get The Casper?

  • Combo sleepers who require comfort and support in a variety of positions
  • Those who sleep on their backs and need greater lumbar support
  • Sleepers who prefer a bouncy, responsive foam mattress.

The complete Casper mattress review can be seen here.

Who Should Get The Puffy?

  • Side sleepers who don’t require a lot of comfort material, such as light and medium-weight side sleepers.
  • Those that sleep on their backs and don’t require as much lumbar support
  • Those looking for a balanced foam feel with a touch of memory foam on top

The complete Puffy mattress review can be seen here.

Casper Vs Puffy Mattress Video Comparison

With the help of our in-depth video review, get a closer look at each of these mattresses. Marten, one of our reviewers, will go over the construction of both beds and provide his thoughts on them.

[youtube url=”https://youtu.be/3R1UFQV1XzY” width=”600″ height=”400″ responsive=”yes” autoplay=”no” mute=”no”]

Similarities Between The Casper And Puffy?

Casper and Puffy are both online-only all-foam mattresses, yet the similarities don’t end there. There are a few other similarities between these two beds.

  • The base foam of both the Casper and Puffy mattresses is similar.
  • The firmness of the Casper and Puffy mattresses is comparable.
  • In terms of price, the beds are comparable, with a Queen bed costing roughly $1100.

Key Differences Between The Casper And Puffy?

Even while the Casper and Puffy share certain similarities, these two beds have a number of significant variances.

  • The Casper mattress is an inch thicker than the Puffy.
  • The top layers of the mattresses are made up of several types of foam.
  • The Casper mattress has a Zoned Support system, but the Puffy does not.
  • They have a somewhat distinct sensation to them: the Casper is bouncy and responsive, but the top of the Puffy responds to pressure more slowly.
  • The Casper mattress features AirScape foam to improve ventilation, whilst the Puffy mattress has a gel infusion in its memory foam comfort layer to help the mattress sleep cooler.

Sizing and Weight Options

When shopping for a new bed, one of the first things you should think about is the size. The majority of mattresses offered now come in six common sizes. The twin, twin XL, and full for single sleepers, as well as the queen, king, and California king for two or more persons, are available. Keep in mind that if your old mattress and new mattress are not the same size, you may need to purchase a new support system.

Another key issue is thickness. Some people like low-profile mattresses (less than 10 inches) because they are closer to the ground, while others prefer high-profile mattresses (more than 12 inches) because they give more padding and comfort for their bodies. For those who like a more balanced thickness, a medium-profile mattress (10 to 12 inches) will suffice.

Finally, double-check the weight of any mattress you’re considering purchasing, especially if it’s from a mattress-in-a-box company. Because these mattresses are brought right to your door, you’ll have to carry them to the room of your choice without the help of a professional.

The tables below provide the weights, heights, and size options for all Puffy and Casper models.

Puffy

Puffy Mattress

  • Height: 10″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Puffy Lux

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Puffy Royal

  • Height: 14″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Puffy Lux Hybrid

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Puffy Royal Hybrid

  • Height: 14″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Casper

Casper Original Mattress

  • Height: 11″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Casper Original Hybrid

  • Height: 11″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Casper Wave Hybrid

  • Height: 13″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Casper Element

  • Height: 10″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Casper Nova Hybrid

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Casper mattress vs. Puffy mattress alternatives are relatively similar in terms of weight, height, and available sizes, as you can see from the tables above. All Puffy and Casper models are available in all six common sizes, making them ideal for single or multiple sleepers. All-foam mattresses are often light, whereas hybrid mattresses are heavier. When carrying any of these mattresses, you may want to enlist the assistance of a roommate, friend, or family member.

Both Puffy and Casper offer beds in a variety of thicknesses, including medium- and high-profile variants. Other brands that sell beds that are less than 10 inches thick might be considered by anyone looking for a low-profile mattress.

Construction and Materials Comparison

The design of a mattress can reveal a lot about it, including how long it will last, whether it will keep a comfortable temperature, and how much it will sink at the edges. The materials used to make the various layers can also influence how soft or firm the mattress feels on the surface, as well as how much it costs.

Puffy

Puffy Mattress

A 2-inch comfort layer of patented Cloud Comfort memory foam is included in the Puffy Mattress. This material is extremely soft and will conform to your body, giving you the feel of a regular memory foam mattress. Although the memory foam is filled with cooling gel to keep the surface cool, we observed that the mattress still absorbs some body heat and sleeps warmly; this is a common attribute among memory foam mattresses.

A 2-inch polyfoam transitional layer sits beneath the memory foam on the Puffy Mattress. This feature is meant to support the comfort layer and keep you from sinking too far into the mattress. Although this model has a medium feel and is not very supportive, the 6-inch support core of high-density polyfoam stabilizes the mattress to keep you on an equal plane and avoid sinkage at the edges. The Puffy Mattress is 10 inches thick all around.

Puffy Lux

The Puffy Lux adds a 1.5-inch comfort layer of gel-infused Cloud Comfort memory foam and a second 1.5-inch comfort layer of adaptable polyfoam to the flagship model. The Puffy Lux is notably plusher as a result of the additional padding layer, despite the fact that it is still classified as a medium-feel mattress. A transitional polyfoam layer and a high-density polyfoam base are also included in this mattress. The Puffy Lux is 12 inches thick, falling between between a medium and a high-profile mattress.

Puffy Lux Hybrid

Except for one thing: the support core architecture, the Puffy Lux Hybrid is nearly identical to the Lux in every way. The Lux Hybrid’s support structure is made up of pocketed coils and a layer of base polyfoam, as opposed to the Lux’s high-density base foam. Because the coils produce some reactivity on the surface, the Lux Hybrid is a better choice than the Lux if you enjoy a bouncy mattress. The Lux Hybrid, on the other hand, has a medium feel and will conform more tightly than many other hybrids.

Puffy Royal

Finally, there are three comfort layers in the Puffy Royal: 1.5 inches of gel-infused Cloud Comfort memory foam, 2 inches of adaptable polyfoam, and a third polyfoam cushioning layer. Although this mattress is softer than the other two Puffy models, it is still classified as a medium firmness mattress.

The transitional polyfoam layer of the Puffy Royal is zoned, which means it feels firmer in areas where people tend to bear more weight, such the stomach and hips, and softer beneath the head and neck, shoulders, and legs. Zoned layers can help sleepers who weigh more than 130 pounds by providing extra support and preventing them from sinking too much. However, because the Puffy Royal follows the body’s contours so closely, certain people – especially those who weigh more than 230 pounds – may still sink. A high-density polyfoam base is also included in this mattress. Puffy’s thickest mattress, with a 14-inch profile, is also taller than any of Casper’s mattresses.

Puffy Royal Hybrid

The Royal Hybrid, like the Lux Hybrid, is inspired by the all-foam Puffy model of the same name. It has the same thickness, firmness, comfort, and transitional layer composition as the Royal, but the support core is made up of pocketed coils rather than foundation foam. The foam layers of the Royal Hybrid are deep enough to provide close, even body contouring, but the coil system gives it a bit more responsiveness.

Puffy mattresses are covered in a 100 percent polyester cover that can be unzipped, removed, and washed in any home machine – however Puffy recommends not washing and drying the cover more than a few times a year to avoid wear and tear.

Casper

Casper Original

Because it has a 1.5-inch polyfoam comfort layer and a zoned, 2-inch memory foam transitional layer, the Casper Original is classified as a mixed-foam mattress. This mattress has a medium feel and provides deep contouring, yet the polyfoam adds responsiveness to the surface, resulting in a light bounce as you get in and out of bed. Although the mattress has a medium feel, you may still experience a lack of support in some spots due to the zoned memory foam, which helps to maintain an even plane without too much sinking beneath heavy sections of your body.

A 7-inch high-density polyfoam support core is also included with the Casper Original. This mattress is 11 inches thick all around.

Casper Hybrid

The Casper Hybrid has many of the same comfort and transitional layers as the flagship mattress. Its support core, on the other hand, is made of pocketed coils rather than base foam. The coils give this mattress a little extra bounce, but overall, the Casper Hybrid isn’t as responsive as other hybrids with similar construction. The coils are encased in high-density foam to keep the edges from sinking too far. The Casper Hybrid, like the Casper Original, is 11 inches thick and has a medium feel.

Casper Element

The company’s other all-foam product is the Casper Element. This mattress has a 3-inch comfort layer made of AirScape polyfoam and a high-density polyfoam support core. This mattress will not contour as tightly as Casper’s other models because it does not contain any memory foam and has a medium firm feel. The Element is also the company’s shortest mattress, at 10 inches thick, however it is still classified as a medium-profile bed.

Casper Nova Hybrid

The Nova Hybrid, one of Casper’s newest mattresses, features a top 1-inch AirScape open-cell polyfoam comfort layer, followed by a second 1.5-inch polyfoam comfort layer divided into three firmness zones. The 2-inch transitional memory foam layer of the Nova Hybrid is also separated into seven firmness zones. The Nova Hybrid provides robust reinforcement for sleepers weighing up to 230 pounds, thanks to its stacked zonal layers – yet it has a medium feel and may sink too much for certain people. For enhanced edge support, the support core is made up of pocketed coils encased in high-density foam. The Nova Hybrid is 12 inches thick all around.

Casper Wave Hybrid

Finally, the Wave Hybrid is Casper’s most expensive and thickest mattress. It’s 13 inches thick and, like the Nova Hybrid, has a medium feel with very near body-conforming properties. This model has a 1-inch perforated AirScape polyfoam comfort layer, followed by a 1.5-inch perforated natural latex layer. A 1.5-inch layer of memory foam with three zones follows. The Wave Hybrid’s 1.5-inch transitional polyfoam layer is additionally zoned with supportive gel pods that cradle your lighter areas while reinforcing the torso, stomach, and waist. The Wave Hybrid’s support core, like Casper’s previous hybrids, is made up of pocketed coils encased in high-density polyfoam.

Casper mattresses are covered in a fabric blend that contains polyester derived from recycled bottles, cotton, rayon, and spandex. For cleaning purposes, these coverings should not be removed. Casper suggests spot-cleaning the fabric if stains emerge.

Average Customer Ratings

We recommend that you read user reviews and ratings for any mattress you’re thinking about buying. These reviews, while subjective and based on personal experiences, provide significant insight into how a mattress feels and works, as well as whether it is worth the money. Most online mattress retailers have reviews on their sites, either on individual product pages or in a separate section – though some are simpler to find and browse than others.

Consumer advocacy groups can also provide useful information about a company’s operations. Individual companies are given letter grades by the Better Business Bureau (BBB) based on their level of customer service, the kind of consumer complaints, and how quickly the company answers to various sales and delivery concerns.

For Puffy and Casper mattresses, you’ll find BBB ratings and a ratings overview below.

Puffy

[table]
Model Average Rating
Puffy Mattress 5/5
Puffy Lux 5/5
Puffy Royal 5/5
Puffy Lux Hybrid
Puffy Royal Hybrid
[/table]

Casper

[table]
Model Average Rating
Casper Original Mattress 4.5/5
Casper Original Hybrid 4.6/5
Casper Wave Hybrid 4.5/5
Casper Element 4.5/5
Casper Nova Hybrid 4.5/5
[/table]

In-Depth Ratings

Based on its thickness, firmness, and material composition, a mattress will function well in some regions and suffer in others. Our performance ratings for each Puffy and Casper mattress are listed below. These scores are based on verifiable user feedback from product reviews and surveys, as well as our own research and analysis. First, we’ll go through each of the performance categories and why they’re important to sleepers.

Durability

The average mattress lasts six to eight years before it needs to be replaced. The most common reason for mattress replacement is that the materials soften and lose support over time, resulting in deep drooping and body impressions on the surface. A new bed may be required if there is excessive sinkage along the edges. All-foam mattresses, on average, last longer than hybrids, although this isn’t always the case. Rotate the bed from head to foot every three to six months to help protect the mattress surface.

Motion Isolation

Materials that absorb movement from sleepers when they change positions or get in and out of bed are found in several mattresses, including most all-foam types. This can keep motion from spreading across the surface and waking up the person’s sleeping spouse. When you and your co-sleeper sleep on a more responsive mattress, like as a hybrid, you’ll likely experience more motion transfer when one of you moves around in bed.

Sex

Although each couple’s preferences differ, most couples agree that responsive mattresses are the greatest for sex. On the surface, good bounciness lets you and your partner to move around freely without sinking too deeply – however a little conforming can also give strong traction when you need to stay in one position for a long time. Mattresses might be affected by edge support during sex. You can use the entire surface of a bed with strong perimeters, whereas versions with weaker edge support may limit you to the middle.

Temperature Neutrality

Certain mattress materials, such as solid polyfoam and memory foam, have a proclivity for absorbing and trapping body heat, making the surface feel uncomfortable. Breathable components like open-cell or ventilated comfort layers, coil designs that promote airflow throughout the interior, and textiles that don’t retain heat help other mattresses sleep cooler. All-foam mattresses typically sleep warmer than hybrids.

Pressure Relief

A mattress should cushion the body without sinking unduly and support uniform spinal alignment to relieve pressure points. As a result, the optimal mattress for pressure reduction will be largely determined by your weight and preferred sleeping position. Most side sleepers choose a more supporting mattress that strengthens their heavier areas, while most back and stomach sleepers prefer a more contoured mattress to promote even alignment and less pressure.

Off-gassing

The “new mattress scent” you’ll notice after unboxing your bed is known as off-gassing. Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) with a distinct chemical odor are the most typical source of off-gassing odours in mattresses with foam layers. In most situations, the stench will go away after a few days, but smelly beds with dense foam components may take a week or longer to clear out.

Ease of Movement

If your mattress sinks too much, it may be difficult to move over it. This sensation is often compared to being stuck in the mattress, and it can make it difficult to move in and out of bed or change sleep positions. A firmer, more responsive mattress won’t sink as much and should allow for easier movement, but this category, like pressure relief, is heavily influenced by your weight.

Edge Support

When you sit at the margins of a mattress with coils and other solid support elements, it may sink a little, but not to the point where you have trouble getting in and out of bed or feel unsafe resting near the perimeter. You may feel less secure sitting or laying along the perimeter of a mattress with poor edge support, especially if you weigh more than 230 pounds.

Puffy

[table]
  Puffy Mattress Puffy Lux Puffy Royal Puffy Lux Hybrid Puffy Royal Hybrid
Firmness Medium (5) Medium (5) Medium (5) Medium (5) Medium (5)
Durability 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Motion Isolation 5/5 5/5 5/5 4/5 4/5
Sex 2/5 2/5 2/5 3/5 3/5
Sleeps Cool 2/5 2/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Pressure Relief 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5
Off-Gassing 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Ease of Movement 2/5 3/5 2/5 3/5 3/5
Edge Support 3/5 3/5 2/5 3/5 3/5
[/table]

Casper

[table]
  Casper Original Mattress Casper Original Hybrid Casper Wave Hybrid Casper Element Casper Nova Hybrid
Firmness Medium (5) Medium (5) Medium (5) Medium Firm (6) Medium (5)
Durability 3/5 3/5 4/5 2/5 4/5
Motion Isolation 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5
Sex 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Sleeps Cool 3/5 4/5 4/5 3/5 3/5
Pressure Relief 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5
Off-Gassing 3/5 3/5 3/5 2/5 3/5
Ease of Movement 3/5 4/5 4/5 3/5 4/5
Edge Support 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
[/table]

In-Depth Pricing

The cost of a new mattress is determined by a number of things. The size you choose, the mattress type and materials utilized in different layers, and the brand itself are all factors to consider. Furthermore, depending on where you purchase the mattress, you may find significant price discrepancies. Due to the significant overhead costs of managing storefronts and paying onsite sales staff, pricing at brick-and-mortar mattress businesses are often higher. Online mattress companies, who have a smaller workforce and few (if any) brick-and-mortar locations, can sell their products at significantly reduced pricing.

In a queen size, an all-foam mattress costs between $900 and $1,200, making it one of the most cheap mattress types. Hybrids are often more expensive, ranging from $1,600 to $2,200 for a queen size.

The tables below show the current costs for all Puffy and Casper mattresses in all sizes.

Puffy

[table]
  Puffy Mattress Puffy Lux Puffy Royal Puffy Lux Hybrid Puffy Royal Hybrid
Twin $899 $1,449 $1,649 $1,449 $1,649
Twin XL $949 $1,499 $1,749 $1,499 $1,749
Full $1099 $1,599 $2,449 $1,599 $2,499
Queen $1,249 $1,799 $2,699 $1,799 $2,699
King $1,449 $1,999 $2,999 $1,999 $2,999
California King $1,449 $1,999 $2,999 $1,999 $2,999
[/table]

 

Casper

[table]
  Casper Original Mattress Casper Original Hybrid Casper Wave Hybrid Casper Element Casper Nova Hybrid
Twin $695 $995 $1,595 $249 $1,195
Twin XL $795 $1,095 $2,195 $299 $1,595
Full $995 $1,295 $2,545 $374 $1,945
Queen $1,095 $1,395 $2,695 $449 $2,095
King $1,495 $1,795 $3,295 $574 $2,695
California King $1,495 $1,795 $3,295 $574 $2,695
[/table]

 

Puffy and Casper both offer mattresses with pricing that are comparable to industry averages, as well as some more expensive versions, as shown in the tables. If you’re on a limited budget, the Casper Element is the most affordable model from either company. This is also the firmest Puffy or Casper mattress available.

When compared to comparable all-foam mattresses, the Puffy Mattress and Casper Original are both reasonably priced. Although the Casper Hybrid costs more than either of these mattresses, it is still a bargain for a memory foam hybrid. The Casper Hybrid is one of the finest selections among all Puffy and Casper models in terms of overall value based on pricing and performance.

The Puffy Lux and Puffy Royal are both pricey memory foam mattresses, and the Lux Hybrid and Royal Hybrid are similarly priced when compared to comparable hybrids. Similarly, the Nova Hybrid and Wave Hybrid feature higher-than-average price tags. All six mattresses have a luxurious surface feel and significant body contouring, but many shoppers may find that they are beyond of their price range.

Trial, Warranty, and Delivery

Shipping

Puffy offers free ground shipping for all mattress orders inside the continental United States, as well as delivery to Alaska and Hawaii for an additional fee. Customers in Alaska, Hawaii, and Canadian territories (Northwest Territories, Yukon, and Nunavut) will have to pay an additional fee for delivery.

The mattresses are compressed, vacuum-sealed in plastic, and delivered in a box to your door for normal ground deliveries. You don’t have to be home when the mattress arrives or sign for it, but you will have to put it together yourself. Carry the box to the room where the mattress will be used, open it, and cut the plastic off with a knife. The mattress should fully inflate within 48 hours of packaging, regardless of whatever Puffy or Casper model you purchase.

White Glove delivery, a full-service option that includes in-home mattress assembly and old mattress removal, is also available from Casper. This service is only offered within the contiguous United States and costs an additional $149, but it may be ideal for people who do not want to put up the mattress themselves and/or have an old bed they no longer want. White Glove delivery is not available for any orders placed with Puffy.

Returns

Most online mattress companies don’t have any physical locations, so you won’t be able to try out their mattresses before making a purchase. Thankfully, most of these companies offer 90-day or longer sleep trials. You can sleep on the mattress during these trials and then decide whether to keep, return, or swap it.

All three Puffy mattresses come with a 101-night sleep trial. Although the business suggests sleeping on the mattress for at least 30 nights before returning it, you only need to try it out for 14 nights to get a complete refund. Puffy will send couriers to collect the mattress from your home and transfer it for donation or recycling at no additional cost in the case of a return. There are no costs for returns.

Casper’s sleep experiment lasts for 100 nights. The required break-in period for this experiment is 30 nights. You can return the mattress for a full refund after 30 nights, and couriers will pick it up from your house. You can also switch the mattress for a different Casper model. You may have to pay the difference in price or obtain a partial refund depending on the original mattress and the replacement you choose. If you choose an exchange, the sleep trial will be void, and you will not be able to return the replacement for a full refund.

Warranties

As an added quality control precaution, manufacturers offer warranties on their products. Manufacturers, not users or owners, are accountable for defective products, according to the warranty. The majority of mattresses offered today come with 10-year or longer warranties.

All three Puffy beds come with a lifetime warranty, which means the mattress is covered for as long as you own it. You won’t have to pay anything to have a damaged mattress fixed or replaced because the guarantee is non-prorated. Sagging and body impressions that are 1.5 inches or deeper, as well as manufacturing faults in the mattress cover, are covered under this warranty.

Casper comes with a ten-year warranty. This guarantee is also entirely non-prorated, so if your mattress develops a flaw, you won’t have to worry about high repair or replacement fees. Sagging and body imprints that are 1 inch or deeper are considered faults under this warranty. Other shortcomings in the mattress include physical weaknesses that cause materials to crack or split early, as well as issues with the cover’s zipper assembly.

It’s important to remember that mattress warranties aren’t transferrable. They are only available to those who buy the mattress straight from the brand or from an authorized retailer; they are not available to people who acquire the bed from the original owner or from an unlicensed shop.

Firmness And Feel Differences

The similarities and contrasts between the Casper and Puffy have a significant impact on the firmness and feel of these mattresses. Let’s take a deeper look at how each mattress feels when you sleep on it.

How Firm Are The Casper And Puffy Mattresses?

On the firmness meter, both the Casper and the Puffy scored around a 7/10. Both beds are slightly stiffer than medium-firm, as the industry norm for medium firmness is 6.5.

It’s worth noting, though, that a person’s weight and stature can influence their perception of a bed’s firmness. The firmness ratings of these mattresses may be ranked differently by various persons.

Sleeping On The Casper And Puffy Mattresses

We slept on the Casper and Puffy mattresses in various positions to test how they felt to us:

Casper

While again sleeping on the Casper, we felt terrific. Our hips were able to sink in a little for pressure relief, but spinal support was not compromised. When we were back sleeping on the Casper, we noticed that the lumbar support was very good.

We only felt fine while sleeping on our sides on the Casper; we didn’t get a lot of pressure relief, thus this posture can become difficult for someone who sleeps on their side all night. Lighter-weight side sleepers, on the other hand, may likely find the Casper mattress to provide more pressure relief.

When we shifted to our stomachs on the Casper, the bed’s support layer provided adequate support. Those who sleep on their stomachs, on the other hand, may want to opt for a firmer mattress with more general support.

Puffy

While again sleeping on the Puffy, we found a wonderful blend of comfort and support. Back sleepers, especially those who don’t require a lot of lumbar support, may find this to be a good fit.

We did felt some pressure around the shoulder and hip while side sleeping on the Puffy. Lighter-weight folks should, however, benefit from improved pressure reduction when resting on their sides on the Puffy.

For stomach sleeping, the Puffy was a little too soft – our hips sunk into the mattress, which threw our spine out of line. Those who sleep on their stomachs should opt for a mattress that is firmer and more supporting.

What Do The Casper And Purple Mattresses Feel Like?

The Casper has a springy, responsive foam feel to it, and it bounced up quite high during our bounce tests. This means that you should be able to move about freely on the Casper mattress.

The Puffy features a well-balanced foam feel with a hint of traditional memory foam on top. The Puffy is a little slower-moving than the Casper due to the memory foam, but it’s not difficult to move around on this mattress.

Average Weight Sleepers – 130 lb – 230 lb

Because it provides a blend of comfort and support, the Casper should be a good fit for average weight back sleepers (especially lumbar support). When resting on the Casper, average-weight side sleepers may experience more pressure than they prefer. For stomach sleepers, the Casper provides adequate support, though those who sleep in this position all night may wish to consider a firmer mattress.

For back sleepers, the Puffy mattress provides adequate support, however the Casper mattress provides better lumbar support. Because of the memory foam on top, people who are on the lighter end of the weight range (near to 130 lb) may find that side sleeping on the Puffy provides adequate pressure relief. For average-weight stomach sleepers, the Puffy is definitely not supportive enough, and they could feel their hips bending into the mattress.

Heavyweight Sleepers – Over 230 lb

Because it should provide adequate lumbar support, the Casper could be a suitable match for heavyweight back sleepers who weigh close to 230 pounds. (People who are significantly heavier should opt for a coil-filled mattress.) It’s not ideal for heavyweight side sleepers, who will experience too much strain around the shoulder and hip. The Casper may be able to handle heavyweight stomach sleepers weighing close to 230 pounds, but it may not be enough for heavier people.

Heavyweight back sleepers may find the Puffy sufficient, but much heavier folks will need to opt for a more supportive mattress with coils. The Puffy, like the Casper, is unlikely to provide enough pressure relief for heavyweight side sleepers. It’s also not a good fit for heavyweight stomach sleepers, as the Puffy is likely to be too soft to provide enough support in this position.

Lightweight Sleepers – Under 130 lb

The Casper mattress provides exceptional lumbar support, making it a good choice for light back sleepers. Despite the fact that the Casper is designed to be softer across the shoulders, lighter-weight side sleepers may not experience enough pressure reduction. The Casper mattress should provide enough support for light stomach sleepers to maintain proper spinal alignment.

The Puffy provides adequate support and comfort for light back sleepers (but it lacks the Casper’s targeted lumbar support). The Puffy’s soft memory foam on top should provide adequate pressure relief for light side sleepers. Lightweight stomach sleepers should find the Puffy to be supportive enough to keep their hips lifted and aligned with their spine.

Casper vs Puffy: Best Qualities

We’ve almost reached the conclusion of this comparison, y’all! It’s time to finish things up with a few last thoughts and recommendations after delving into the constructions of these beds and comparing how they feel.

First and foremost, if you’re a sleeper in need of significant lower-back support, I recommend the Casper mattress. This bed not only has a pleasingly balanced feel, but it also has an inside layer of zoned support that helps to keep the spine in a neutral line from the shoulders to the hips. This could be relaxing for all types of sleepers, but especially for those who suffer from nighttime back pain. The Casper is also softer than the Puffy, making it a good choice for combo sleepers.

When it comes to the Puffy mattress, I believe it’s best for side sleepers or people who suffer from joint problems. Despite the fact that both the Casper and the Puffy use memory foam in their constructions, I would only classify the Puffy as a memory foam mattress, which means it’s velvety, pressure-relieving, and designed to make you feel more “in” the bed than “on top” of it. The Puffy could be the bed for you if you’re searching for a fuzzy hug from your mattress as you sleep.

I’m going to wrap things up with some of my favorite elements of each mattress to go even more precise about my suggestions.

Casper Best Qualities

  • I believe the Casper mattress would be an excellent choice for people who suffer from back problems. Its inside layer of zoned support helps to raise and place the spine in a healthy, neutral alignment, and it has a warm, balanced sensation.
  • The mattress’s balanced foam feel should appeal to a wide range of sleepers. So, if you haven’t yet figured out how you sleep, you’ll probably appreciate the Casper.

Puffy Best Qualities 

  • You can’t go wrong with the Puffy if you want a plush memory foam feel. This mattress exemplifies all of the material’s best qualities, including sinkage, pressure reduction, and body contouring.
  • In fact, everyone who suffers from joint pain in the shoulders and hips would appreciate the deep pressure relief provided by this bed.

Puffy vs. Casper Mattress – Which One Should You Buy

Even with all of these considerations in mind, deciding between Puffy and Casper may seem difficult. We’ve outlined the main differences between these two mattresses so you can quickly compare them while determining which mattress is right for you.

Buy the Puffy mattress if you:

1. Want superior motion isolation

Puffy’s memory foam comfort layer isolates motion better than Casper, which is distinguished by having more bounce and resilience than the normal memory foam mattress. This makes it a perfect alternative for sensitive sleepers with tossing and turning partners.

2. Want more responsive temperature control

Unlike most memory foam mattresses, Puffy boasts not one, but two temperature-controlling layers. The mattress will not only maintain a pleasant temperature during the night, but it will also provide cooling or warming properties depending on seasonal temperature fluctuations.

3. Want a lifetime warranty

Unlike Casper, which only gives a 10-year limited guarantee, Puffy offers a lifetime warranty, allowing you to replace your mattress whenever you need it.

Buy the Casper mattress if you:

1. Want a bouncier and more resilient mattress

The Casper is known for its superior bounce and resilience to both regular memory foam and Puffy mattresses. This makes it a good choice for sexual activity and active sleepers.

2. Want a memory foam mattress with edge support

Because the bulk of memory foam mattresses have insufficient edge support, Casper’s optional hybrid add-on gives it a significant benefit. Keep in mind that this will cost you back an additional $200, but you’ll get better support, a pocketed coil support core, and better cooling.

3. Need a brand with a more established reputation

Casper has been operating for three years longer than Puffy, so you’ll have access to a lot more reviews and journalistic coverage when conducting your study. It’s also the most well-known brand, and its mattresses have been on the market long enough for customers to comment on their durability.

Casper And Puffy Mattress FAQs

We’d like to address some of the most frequently asked questions about Casper and Puffy mattresses right now.

Which mattress is better, Casper or Puffy?

Although neither mattress is superior to the other, they may be more suited to various types of sleepers.

The Casper is a good choice for combo sleepers, back sleepers who want a lot of lumbar support, and sleepers who prefer a bouncy foam mattress.

The Puffy is ideal for light to medium-weight side sleepers, back sleepers who don’t require as much lumbar support, and people who prefer a balanced foam feel with a hint of memory foam on top.

How long will the Casper and Puffy mattresses last?

Both of these all-foam beds should last about 7 years if all other conditions remain constant.

Which mattress is better for side sleepers, Casper or Puffy?

Because of its memory foam comfort layer, which provides a little more pressure relief than the Casper, the Puffy is best for light- and medium-weight side sleepers. For heavyweight side sleepers, neither mattress is a good fit.

 

Rate this post