Saatva vs. Amerisleep Mattress Comparison: Which Is Best? Update 05/2024

There are a variety of options for clients to choose from at Saatva and Amerisleep, according on their body shape and sleeping preference.

In terms of firmness and thickness, the Saatva Classic coil-on-coil hybrid is the company’s top model. The Saatva HD, a hybrid mattress for persons who weigh more than 230 pounds, and the Saatva Latex Hybrid, a mattress made from eco-friendly materials, are also available from Saatva. The Saatva Youth, a reversible innerspring for youngsters, is also available. With so many different body types to choose from, Saatva is an excellent option for customers who are fed up with limited options from other mattress providers.

As a result, Amerisleep does its best to meet a wide range of customer needs. There are a total of five different firmness levels of memory foam mattresses made by the company. Amerisleep is able to meet the needs of the majority of different sleeper types thanks to its five different models. As a result, Amerisleep may appeal to environmentally concerned consumers who want the feel of an all-foam mattress. It has recently become possible for some Amerisleep models to be offered as hybrid models with coil-based support instead of polyfoam cores.

As far as value goes, both firms provide excellent goods that will outlast the ordinary mattress. We’ll examine Amerisleep and Saatva mattresses in-depth so you can make an informed decision about which mattress is best for you.

Amerisleep vs. Saatva Overview

It’s no surprise that Amerisleep is one of the most popular bed-in-a-box brands on the market today. This comparison focuses on the Amerisleep AS3 Hybrid, which is a hybrid mattress. This mattress, one of Amerisleep’s best-sellers, is ideal for a wide range of people.

As a luxury internet mattress company, Saatva doesn’t cram their beds into cardboard boxes like many other companies. Models such as the Saatva Latex Hybrid, Loom & Leaf, and Solaire are popular. As a starting point, we’ll examine Saatva Classic’s 11.5-inch Luxury Firm mattress.

Despite the fact that both mattresses have outstanding features, some people prefer one over the other. In the meantime, here’s a short look at who might like each bed.

Who Should Get the Amerisleep?

  • Those who prefer a more moderately firm bed.
  • There are a lot of back sleepers out there.
  • Couples.

Who Should Get the Saatva?

  • who like a mattress with a higher degree of firmness
  • Sleepers who prefer to rest their heads on their stomachs
  • who are unable to wait for their mattress to decompress and open up

Amerisleep vs. Saatva: Top Similarities

When comparing mattresses, we always begin by looking at the similarities between the two brands. Check out the similarities between Amerisleep and Saatva beds!

  • The responsiveness of the Saatva and Amerisleep mattresses is evident.
  • They’re both hybrid mattresses with foam on top and coils underneath.
  • There is a lot to like about both.
  • Both sleep trial periods and return policies are fairly generous.
  • The customer support provided by Saatva and Amerisleep is widely regarded as excellent.

Amerisleep vs. Saatva: Key Differences

This time, let’s examine the differences between these two mattresses.

  • The Saatva mattress, on the other hand, has a more firm feel.
  • In terms of height, the Amerisleep is 12′′, while the Saatva may be purchased in 11.5′′ and 14.5′′ sizes.
  • The items sold by Amerisleep are a little more expensive (but customers can save with coupons).
  • In order for Amerisleep to expand and off-gas, it must be sent in a box. When it comes to Saatva’s delivery, they do it with a smile.
  • If you want to sleep on your stomach, Saatva is your best bet.

Sizing and Weight Options

The size, height, and weight of a mattress are among the first things to consider when making a mattress purchase. If so, what kind of bed frame will you be using it on? Do you have a restricted amount of floor space? If you can’t find a mattress in the size you require, it’s possible you’ll have to remove it from consideration.

When it comes to getting in and out of bed, those with mobility challenges may benefit from a mattress and base that are elevated off the floor at a comfortable height. As a side note, deep-pocket fitted sheets may be necessary for mattresses with higher than typical height profiles.

In the event that you plan to move your mattress frequently, the weight of the mattress is the most crucial consideration. As an added bonus, setting up and rotating larger mattresses can be more difficult when they’re bulky. As a general rule, heavier mattresses are made of latex or memory foam, whereas lighter mattresses are made of polyurethane foam or polyurethane foam.

Saatva and Amerisleep mattresses have been compared side by side to help you decide which one is best for your bedroom.


Saatva Classic

  • Height: 11.5″, 14.5″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Split King, California King, Split California King

Saatva HD

  • Height: 15.5″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King

Saatva Youth

  • Height: 10″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full

Saatva Latex Hybrid

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King



  • Height: 10″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King


  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King


  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King


  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King


  • Height: 14″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King

The Saatva Youth mattress is only available in twin, twin XL, and full sizes, while all other mattresses come in the regular six sizes. To accommodate couples with adjustable bed bases, the Saatva Classic is available as an adjustable-bed option in split King and split California King sizes. The Saatva HD, Saatva Latex Hybrid, and all Amerisleep mattresses are also available in a split king size option.

The thickness of Amerisleep mattresses ranges from 10 to 14 inches, depending on whether they are firm or plush. Saatva Classic consumers, on the other hand, have the option of choosing between an 11.5-inch or 14.5-inch profile with no variation in feel. The Saatva HD is taller than the ordinary mattress because of its several layers of support. Despite its shorter length, the Saatva Latex Hybrid mattress is still considered a high-profile mattress at 12 inches thick.

You may rest assured that all Amerisleep mattresses feature memory foam comfort layers. Saatva HD and Saatva Latex Hybrid are hybrids, as are the Saatva Classic and Saatva Youth, which are classified as innersprings. If you have a preference for one sort of mattress over the other, you can easily choose between Amerisleep and Saatva. As a result, folks who have difficulty carrying heavy objects may want to select all-foam mattresses over hybrid mattresses.

Construction and Materials Comparison

Most mattress manufacturers have landed on a small number of materials that work well in mattresses after years of trial and error. There are a wide range of materials that can be used to make a mattress, including memory foam, polyfoam, latex, cotton, wool, and micro-coils.

In order to cater to a wide range of slumber preferences, mattress makers can adjust the firmness, quality, and other characteristics of their products. For the most part, the components of a mattress determine whether it’s an all-foam, innerspring, hybrid, latex, or even an airbed model. Even though two mattresses of the same type have some similarities, their individual compositions will provide each one distinct advantages and disadvantages.

When it comes to design and materials, Saatva and Amerisleep are poles apart. We’ll look into the materials used in the construction of each mattress and talk about how that affects the quality of your sleep.


Saatva Classic

The Saatva Classic mattress has a luxurious Euro top and a coil-on-coil construction, making it a cross between an innerspring and a hybrid mattress.

  • Soft polyfoam, fiber fill, and 1 oz. Dacron sewed into the Eurotop.
  • Polyfoam sheet 625 inches wide
  • Lumbar support with 375-inch memory foam
  • A four-inch layer of pocketed coil (foam-encased)
  • (11.25-inch) or (7.5″ profile) (14.5-inch profile) coils that resemble an hourglass
  • 5 and 875-inch-long fibre pads
  • Encased in a layer of foam.

In addition to providing the bounce of an innerspring mattress, the twin layer of coils keeps the mattress at a consistent temperature. Dacron-filled soft and medium variants have a quilted organic cotton cover that provides additional padding. The Saatva mattress has a high-density polyfoam encasement around the perimeter, which provides targeted lumbar support and prevents movement.

The Saatva Classic mattress is available in Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm firmness levels. Most people should be able to find a level of firmness that works for them among the three possibilities. Customers can also pick between an 11.5-inch or 14.5-inch profile for practical reasons. Mattresses with different hourglass coil heights don’t feel any different.

Saatva HD

In order to support sleepers that weigh more than 300 pounds, the Saatva HD has a strong construction.

  • Cotton that is grown without the use of pesticides (quilted in pillow top)
  • A Talalay latex thickness of 1.5 inches (5 zones)
  • Memory foam with a thickness of 1.5 inches
  • Polyfoam insulation is 2 inches thick.
  • Polyfoam-encased offset coils

Pressure alleviation and support for heavier sleepers are provided by features including zoned latex, active wire lumbar support, and larger coils. The latex and innerspring support core of the Saatva HD mattress makes it extremely breathable and simple to move around on. Similar to Saatva Classic’s organic cotton cushion top and reinforced perimeter.

Saatva Latex Hybrid

Latex Hybrid provides outstanding support and a long-lasting construction that incorporates certain eco-friendly components.

  • Organic cotton cover with GOTS certification
  • Organic wool fire barrier certified by GOTS
  • Ventilated Talalay latex 8-inch zoned coils (14.5-gauge perimeter, 13.75-gauge interior)
  • “Eco Loft” is an organic “Eco Loft”

It’s a good choice for those who prefer a coil mattress but don’t enjoy the feel of memory foam. Although latex conforms to the body pleasantly, it does not sink as deeply or trap as much body heat as memory foam. Additionally, the Saatva Latex Hybrid mattress sleeps cool because of its organic cotton cover and continuous ventilation through the coil system.

The mattress’s edge support is an additional perk. In order to promote bounce-back and decrease sinkage, thicker coils are positioned around the perimeter of the thick pocketed coils. Getting on and off the bed should be simple for most people, even those who weigh more than 230 pounds. Latex is naturally resistant to wear and tear, thus the edges should last for a long time.

Saatva Youth

Youngsters between the ages of 3 and 12 can use the Saatva Youth, which has two sides suitable to their growth.

  • Polyfoam is used on both sides of the record.
  • SIDE TWO: HD polyfoam that has been twisted
  • Coils with reversible Bonnells

For youngsters aged 3 to 8, the most comfortable side of the flippable innerspring mattress is on the other side. With time, youngsters can go to Side 1, which features zoned polyfoam and lumbar support. Children’s Saatva Youth mattress features a waterproof barrier to keep messes out of the mattress, as well as robust borders and a soft organic cotton cover.


According to our tests, the AS5 mattress from Amerisleep is the firmest of the five mattresses, with a medium-soft feel.

Medium-density memory foam is the same for all mattresses despite their differing volumes. ILD, or indentation load deflection, is also a factor in altering firmness and support between mattresses in the transitional layers. Only the AS1 mattress features a significantly thicker and harder support core than the rest of the Amerisleep mattresses.

In a few variants, the high-density polyfoam base is replaced with a bed of individually pocketed coils. At the expense of some contouring and motion isolation, the hybrid models offer additional bounce and breathability.


The AS1 is the firmest mattress in Amerisleep’s lineup:

  • 2 inches of memory foam (Bio-Pur, open-cell).
  • 8 inches of high-density polyfoam (Bio-Core).

The AS1 has just a single layer of memory foam over the high-density polyfoam support core. The BioPur memory foam is a plant-based, open-cell foam designed to sleep cooler than traditional memory foam. The foam used in the support core is firmer than the other Amerisleep mattresses. Overall, the AS1 provides slight contouring but keeps the sleeper firmly on top of the mattress, making it ideal for back and stomach sleepers.


Additional cradling is provided by the AS2’s additional layer:

  • It’s 2 inches of memory foam (Bio-Pur, open-cell)
  • 3 inches of polyfoam transitional (zoned with Surface Modification Technology)
  • Polyfoam with a density of 7 inches (Bio-Core)

Adding the transitional layer offers this mattress a somewhat softer feel than the AS1 with zonation that helps deliver tailored pressure relief and support. It’s best for those who weigh between 130 and 230 pounds on their backs or sides, as well as people who weigh less than 130 pounds on their backs or stomachs, to use this mild pressure relief.

Individually pocketed coils instead of a polyfoam foundation are also available for the AS2.


In order to improve the top comfort layer, the AS3 sacrifices a millimeter of the transition layer.

  • Memory foam 3 inches thick (Bio-Pur, open-cell)
  • 2 inches of polyfoam transition (zoned with Surface Modification Technology)
  • Polyfoam with a density of 7 inches (Bio-Core)

A real medium-density feel is achieved by adding an additional layer of memory foam. Zoned transitional layers provide tailored support and pressure alleviation, just like on the AS2. Compared to the AS2, the transitional layer is softer, making the bed feel more luxurious. The AS3 should provide pressure alleviation and good spinal support for back and side sleepers under 230 pounds.

Instead of a polyfoam base, the AS3 hybrid mattress has individually pocketed coils.


The AS4 focuses solely on memory foam’s top layer:

  • Memory foam in a 4-inch layer (Bio-Pur, open-cell)
  • Transitional polyfoam is 1 inch thick (zoned with Surface Modification Technology)
  • Polyfoam with a density of 7 inches (Bio-Core)

For side sleepers, the AS4 provides deep cradling thanks to a thick layer of memory foam and just one inch of soft transitional polyfoam. This provides the feeling of sleeping “in” rather than “on” the bed. As before, the transitional layer is even softer than the previous one, but its support core stays the same


The additional layer in the AS5 makes it the most supple of the Amerisleep mattresses.

  • Memory foam 3 inches thick (Bio-Pur, open-cell)
  • 2 inches of polyfoam transitional (ActiveFlex)
  • Transitional polyfoam is 2 inches thick (zoned with Surface Modification Technology)
  • Polyfoam with a density of 7 inches (Bio-Core)

The ActiveFlex polyfoam from Amerisleep is a convoluted polyfoam that is meant to relieve pressure quickly. It’s soft and cushy, but not as soft as memory foam. For side sleepers and people who weigh less than 130 pounds, the AS5 mattress’ polyfoam and memory foam layers work together to deliver profound pressure relief. Because of the large comfort layer part, the bed has an extra-high profile, which should be taken into consideration while purchasing fitted sheets.

Individually pocketed coils instead of a polyfoam substrate are also available as an option for the AS5 model.

Average Customer Ratings

It’s a good idea to seek a second opinion once you’ve decided on a mattress. This can be done by reading the reviews of customers who have already purchased the mattress.

The mattress’s quality can be judged by the amount of good reviews it has received. Reviews from consumers who have had the mattress for more than a year can also give an idea of its longevity. If you’re curious whether a certain phase-change cover is effective at keeping the mattress cool, you can get some insight from customer evaluations.

In your hunt for the perfect mattress, customer evaluations are an invaluable resource, but they can also lead you astray. It is inevitable that you will come across opposing viewpoints or viewpoints that don’t relate to your own scenario when researching the subject of mattress layers. Make sure to read evaluations from others who have comparable demands to yours before making a decision. Be on the lookout for evaluations that have been paid for or written by people who aren’t actually customers.

We’ve included the global scores for Saatva and Amerisleep mattresses to get you started.


Model Average Rating
Saatva Classic 4.9/5
Saatva HD 4.9/5
Saatva Youth
Saatva Latex Hybrid


Model Average Rating
AS1 4.5/5
AS2 4.5/5
AS3 4.5/5
AS4 4.5/5
AS5 4.5/5

In-Depth Ratings

When it comes to mattresses, there is no such thing as a one-size-fits-all guideline. There is a mattress out there for every type of sleeper, just as each individual sleeper has their own style. We’ve broken down the aspects that have the most impact on the mattress’s feel in order to help you decide which qualities are most essential to you.


In the beginning, a lower-quality mattress performs as well as a more expensive one, but it wears out soon. When a mattress begins to sag and loses its ability to relieve and support the wearer, it must be replaced immediately. Higher-quality mattresses can last far longer, allowing you to get more value out of your investment.

Motion Isolation

Sharing a bed necessitates the use of a mattress that prevents motion transfer between the two sides. This is especially important for people who have trouble falling asleep since they are easily startled by even the slightest movement of their bed companion. Memory foam, for example, is typically the greatest material for motion isolation. Locally, they can flex, absorbing motion and minimizing nighttime interruptions.


The greatest sex mattresses are built of responsive materials that allow for easy movement. Most individuals choose bouncy latex or hybrid mattresses for intimate activities because they are more responsive to the body’s motions. Noise, temperature control, and edge support are additional considerations.

Temperature Neutrality

When it comes to temperature neutrality, some materials perform better than others, making it difficult to get a good night’s rest. Choose a latex or hybrid mattress if you tend to overheat while you sleep. Additionally, look for mattresses that keep you on top of the mattress rather than sinking into it.

Pressure Relief

Their body shape and preferred sleeping position greatly determine how the mattress interacts with them. Mattresses that contour to the body and alleviate pressure points may be ideal for some sleepers. Some people need firmer surfaces to prevent pressure points from forming, while others need softer ones to allow their bodies to sink deeper into the mattress. Most people choose a mattress that falls somewhere in the middle of these two extremes.


Off-gassing is the term used to describe the odor you may detect when you open the mattress box. Off-gassing is a result of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) coming into contact with the air during the synthetic foam manufacturing process. After a few days of letting the mattress air out, most individuals discover that the stench is gone. Natural mattresses, on the other hand, may be preferred by those who have a strong aversion to odors.

Ease of Movement

Mixing and matching sleeping positions necessitates a mattress that allows you to move freely. Close-conforming mattresses have numerous advantages, but they might produce a feeling of being “imprisoned” in the bed for some people. Mattresses designed for active sleepers should have a firmer surface and respond quickly to pressure, making it easier to switch positions during the night.

Edge Support

Sitting or sleeping towards the edge of your mattress may feel like you’re falling out, due to drooping in the mattress’ perimeter. People who have difficulty getting in and out of bed may benefit from mattresses with reinforced edges, such as those seen in hybrid models.


Saatva Classic Saatva HD Saatva Youth Saatva Latex Hybrid
Firmness Soft (3), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8) Firm (7) Medium (5), Firm (7) Medium Firm (6)
Durability 4/5 4/5 3/5 3/5
Motion Isolation 3/5 2/5 3/5 3/5
Sex 3/5 4/5 N/A/5 4/5
Sleeps Cool 4/5 5/5 3/5 4/5
Pressure Relief 4/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Off-Gassing 5/5 4/5 3/5 4/5
Ease of Movement 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5
Edge Support 4/5 4/5 3/5 4/5


Firmness Firm (7) Medium Firm (6) Medium (5) Medium Soft (4) Soft (3)
Durability 3/5 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5
Motion Isolation 3/5 4/5 4/5 5/5 5/5
Sex 3/5 3/5 3/5 2/5 3/5
Sleeps Cool 4/5 3/5 3/5 2/5 2/5
Pressure Relief 3/5 4/5 4/5 5/5 5/5
Off-Gassing 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5 2/5
Ease of Movement 3/5 3/5 3/5 2/5 2/5
Edge Support 4/5 3/5 2/5 2/5 2/5

In-Depth Pricing

Regardless of your financial situation, you may choose a mattress that is both comfortable and supportive. In addition to this, higher-quality materials may offer additional advantages, such as a more pleasant feel or a longer lifespan. Factors that impact a mattress’s price include:

  • The kind of mattress you use (innerspring, hybrid, all-foam, latex, or airbed)
  • The thickness of each layer
  • The materials and certifications of the products
  • The country of origin of the components used in the production of the product.
  • Total height
  • Features that can only be found in certain places

If a mattress costs more, it doesn’t necessarily mean it’s better. Then there’s the possibility that you’ll come across a top-of-the-line model that’s pricey but doesn’t fit your body shape. Be sure to take into account your personal preferences while evaluating the mattress’s price.

Because of the growth of Christmas discounts and direct-to-consumer mattress providers, most customers can afford quality mattresses. A good example of companies that focus on making their products more accessible to the common person is Saatva and Amerisleep.


Saatva Classic Saatva HD Saatva Youth Saatva Latex Hybrid
Twin $887 $1,574 $699 $1,149
Twin XL $1,087 $1,687 $799 $1,274
Full $1,474 $2,074 $899 $1,649
Queen $1,574 $2,674 $1,849
King $1,974 $2,974 $2,249
California King $1,974 $2,974 $2,249
Split King $2,174 $3,374 $2,548
Split California King $2,174


Twin $1,049 $1,249 $1,449 $1,649 $1,949
Twin XL $1,099 $1,299 $1,499 $1,699 $1,999
Full $1,249 $1,449 $1,649 $1,849 $2,149
Queen $1,299 $1,499 $1,699 $1,899 $2,199
King $1,599 $1,799 $1,999 $2,199 $2,499
California King $1,599 $1,799 $1,999 $2,199 $2,499
Split King $1,898 $2,298 $2,698 $3,098 $3,698
Split California King

Saatva and Amerisleep have different pricing models, so we’ll break them down separately in this research..

The Saatva Classic mattress is the best value of the Saatva mattresses, with a low-to-average price tag. Any sleeper would be wise to invest in this mattress with its dual-coil structure and high-quality materials. In reality, the predicted lifespan of all three Saatva mattresses is quite long. There’s a $150 savings compared to White Glove delivery prices from other manufacturers with these products, which are delivered free of charge.

The Saatva HD is built to resist more wear and tear, featuring a latex coating and a sturdy design. These features come at a larger cost, but for heavier people, it can be worth it. Compared to the Saatva Latex HD, the Saatva Latex Hybrid costs less and is in line with the average hybrid model’s price. The Saatva Youth, on the other hand, is more reasonable, but given that it’s designed for youngsters who are still growing, some parents may find it a bit pricey.

Price is closely proportional to the thickness of the mattress’s comfort layers, which in turn affect the mattress’s overall height. The firm AS1 mattress, at an average price for an all-foam mattress, is the most cheap option. The AS5 mattress, with its more intricate construction and higher price, is the top of the line.

Saatva Classic clients pay the same fee regardless of firmness, but Amerisleep customers must pay the equal amount for their preferred firmness level.

Trials, Warranty, and Delivery


The innovation of mattress-in-a-box delivery, in which the mattress is shrink-wrapped, compressed, and shipped directly to the customer’s home via ground shipping, has made the online mattress market conceivable. Shipping normally takes a few days and is usually free in the continental United States. It’s as simple as removing the plastic and allowing the mattress to expand.

Many companies offer White Glove delivery for mattresses that can’t be compacted, or for clients who need assistance putting the mattress together. Third-party delivery teams are available for an additional fee to set up the mattress and even remove your old mattress if necessary.

FedEx delivers Amerisleep’s boxed mattresses to the continental United States for free. To inquire about delivery to Hawaii, Alaska, Canada, or other international locations, please contact Amerisleep. Customers who purchase an adjustable bed frame may be able to arrange White Glove delivery through a third-party service provider.

White Glove delivery is included in the price of all Saatva mattresses. Customers who prefer to have their old mattress removed at no additional cost can do so at checkout. Outside of the United States, Saatva does not ship.


It is well accepted that a few minutes in a showroom does not give a realistic impression of how a mattress will feel after a full night’s sleep. A sleep trial of at least 90 nights is standard for internet mattress purchases. Customers can return the mattress for a refund once they’ve had enough time to use it.

Because a de-compressed mattress cannot be shipped back in its original box, the company will usually send someone to pick up the mattress. They’ll make sure it’s given away or recycled in an environmentally friendly way. Returning mattresses may be subject to a minor restocking cost, which varies from company to company.

For the first 100 nights, Amerisleep requires a 30-night break-in period. The cost of returning an item is non-existent. A refund or a different firmness model can be chosen by customers during the sleep trial.

Saatva provides a 180-night trial period for their mattresses. There is no minimum break-in period, but the corporation charges a $99 processing fee for returns.


Customers are covered by the mattress warranty after the trial period has ended. Mattress guarantees are designed to address manufacture and workmanship flaws, such as permanent body indentations and sagging, which are covered under the warranty. Normal wear and tear and mattresses that have been abused, overused, inadequately cared for, or used without a sufficiently solid foundation are not covered by these warranties…

Customers may have to pay an increasing percentage of the repair or replacement costs over the course of the warranty period, even though the guarantee itself is free. Mattress returns may also incur shipping or handling fees.

The Saatva Youth comes with a 12-year warranty, while the Saatva Classic, Saatva Latex Hybrid, and the Saatva HD each have a 15-year warranty and a 20-year warranty, respectively. Visible indentations of at least a half-inch are covered by the warranty in all Saatva models, save the Saatva HD, which has a 1.5-inch minimum depression threshold. Returning a mattress after the first two years will result in a $99 shipping fee for each way. The Fairness Replacement Option allows customers who have a damaged mattress to exchange it for a new one at a reduced price (plus shipping costs).

A 20-year prorated warranty covers noticeable indentations of at least 0.75 inches on all Amerisleep mattresses. The firm reserves the right to repair or replace defective mattresses after the first decade. In addition to shipping and handling expenses, consumers will be charged for 50% of the replacement price.

Firmness and Feel Differences

The hardness and feel of a mattress are always crucial factors to consider when making a purchase. While some people like something softer and more sluggish, others need a bit more assistance. What kind of mattress is best for you?

How Firm Are the Saatva and Amerisleep Mattresses?

The Amerisleep AS3 mattress scores a 6.5/10 on our firmness scale, which places it in the classic medium-firm category. The Amerisleep AS3 provides excellent comfort and support because to its Bio-Pur foam top and coils underneath.

Our firmness scale rates the Saatva Luxury Firm at a 7 out of 10. In other words, the Saatva is an excellent option if you prefer a firmer mattress than the industry norm. The pillow top gives a layer of comfort, while the coils provide a solid foundation.

Sleeping on the Amerisleep and Saatva Mattresses

For back sleepers, the Amerisleep AS3 is an excellent choice. The lumbar area is supported by the foundation layer, allowing back sleepers to maintain good posture throughout the night. The Amerisleep AS3 mattress, like the Saatva, is a good option for side sleepers. The memory foam comfort layer may cause some people to sink into it and experience some strain on their shoulders. The AS3 is a good choice for stomach sleepers, but they may prefer the firmness level of the Amerisleep AS1.

In terms of back sleepers, Saatva is an excellent choice. Since the lumbar area is well supported, this mattress has been rated as one of the finest mattresses for lower back pain and sciatica. For side sleepers, the Saatva Luxury Firm mattress is a good option. However, some people may prefer a softer mattress. In general, stomach sleepers should enjoy this mattress, however it all depends on one’s body type.

What Do the Amerisleep and Saatva Mattresses Feel Like?

You won’t feel hemmed in by the Amerisleep AS3’s thick layers because it’s springy and responsive. On top of this mattress, you can still easily move around.

The Saatva mattress, despite its soft pillow top comfort layer, nevertheless maintains a typical innerspring feel. I don’t sink too far into the mattress while I’m lying down, and there’s still plenty of bounce.

Average Weight Sleepers – 130lbs – 230lbs

The Amerisleep AS3 is an excellent choice for back sleepers who weigh between 130 and 230 pounds. Average-weight side sleepers, on the other hand, may be put off by the firmness of this bed. We recommend the Amerisleep AS4 or AS5 if you’re primarily a side sleeper. In general, the AS3 is a good option for stomach sleepers of moderate weight because of its hardness, which should keep hips from sinking too far.

The Saatva mattress is ideal for back sleepers of average weight. The lower back is supported by the coils, while the hips are cushioned by the comfort layers. While the Saatva Luxury Stiff mattress may be ideal for side sleepers, people who weigh more than 230 pounds may find it uncomfortably firm. We recommend the Saatva Plush Soft variant if you require greater pressure reduction. The average person’s weight should be well-supported when stomach sleeping. For those who like a more supportive night’s sleep, this mattress is a good choice.

Heavyweight Sleepers – Over 230lbs

As a result of its zoned coils, the Amerisleep AS3 is a good choice for back sleepers who weigh a lot. As heavier people sleep on their side, they may feel some pressure on their shoulders as they press against the top layer of the mattress’s padding. This mattress isn’t ideal for stomach sleepers, either. People in this group may notice their hips sinking deeply into the foam layer, which could contribute to back pain over time for these individuals. It’s recommended to look for a mattress specifically designed for heavier persons if you’re a stomach sleeper.

Back sleepers who weigh in at or over 230 pounds may consider the Saatva Luxury Firm mattress. The Saatva HD is a better option for those who weigh more than 300 pounds. The Saatva is a good option for larger side sleepers. However, some people may feel a tingling sensation in their shoulders and hips. Those who frequently sleep on their stomachs require a firmer mattress. Saatva Luxury Firm customers who fall into this category may notice their hips sinking.

Lightweight Sleepers – Under 130lbs

The Amerisleep AS3 is a good choice for back sleepers who are light in weight. Lightweight folks, on the other hand, may experience severe pressure while side sleeping. Check out our list of the best soft mattresses if you fall into this group. They should be able to alleviate the pain in your shoulders and hips. On the other side, stomach sleepers will find the Amerisleep AS3 to be an excellent alternative. Those who prefer to sleep on their stomachs should look for a mattress that is firm enough to maintain their bodies in proper alignment.

The Saatva Luxury Firm mattress is an excellent choice for light sleepers, regardless of their preferred sleeping position. An outstanding combination of comfort and support is provided by the base coils and the soft pillow top.

Saatva vs Amerisleep: Best Mattress Qualities

We’ve come to the end of this comparison, folks. Following our comparison of the various mattresses, let’s see what the experts have to say about each one. Here, I’ll discuss who I think would enjoy each of these beds.

First and foremost, I believe the Saatva is best suited for those who like a mattress that is firm, supportive, and springy. Innerspring mattresses have buoyant lifts built into them to put the sleeper more “on top” than “within,” and this mattress is no exception. This is a great alternative if you want a more classic look and feel, or if you’re shopping for someone who values quality craftsmanship. Couples may also find this mattress to be a great choice! Why? The inside coil system is encased in a layer of high-density poly foam edge support, which helps to increase the mattress’ useful surface area. In other words, if you and your bed partner want to take a break from hugging or want to switch up your sleeping position, you may go all the way to the edge of the bed and sleep there!

In terms of the Amerisleep mattress, I believe it is best suited for back sleepers who are looking for an all-foam mattress experience. Like the Saatva, it is solid and supporting, but it does so in a more balanced and gentle manner. The top layer of memory foam provides a great amount of cushioning, but it shouldn’t overwhelm you. Amerisleep’s mattress is supplied in a box, which can make it easier to go to sleep if you like that method of transportation. In addition, I’d like to point out that Amerisleep offers five different mattress alternatives, including the AS2. So, regardless matter whether you want a firmer or softer mattress, this brand has you covered!

Saatva Best Features

  • The Saatva innerspring mattress’ solid support may be particularly appealing to back sleepers.
  • The coil-on-coil construction, which makes it easy to move around and change positions, may also be beneficial to those who sleep in multiple positions.
  • Finally, I’d recommend this mattress to couples. For all types of sleepers, the foam edge support is a definite plus!

Amerisleep Best Features

  • Pressure alleviation and support at the shoulders, hips and lower back are provided by this mattress for back sleepers who need it most.
  • Memory foam mattresses that don’t get too hot to sleep on can be achieved using the Amerisleep range of mattresses. You may want to consider Amerisleep if you’ve stayed away from the material because of its reputation for absorbing heat.
  • The Amerisleep brand offers a wide range of firmness options, which should be appealing to a large range of people. Again, the AS1 is the most firm, while the AS5 is the softest. It’s the amount of memory foam in the top layer that sets these mattresses apart.

Should you buy Amerisleep or Saatva?

They really are two separate goods. Amerisleep beds are made for those of you who value warm coziness above everything else. They do give you the impression that you’re floating above the ground.

Instead than relying solely on cutting-edge innovation, Saatva relies on technology that dates back decades. This adds a lot of heft and responsiveness.

Aside from personal preference and whether or not you’re seeking for a specific product, it’s all up to you. Both beds are excellently suited to their intended purpose. The Saatva is a good option if you prefer to sleep on your stomach. These mattresses are all good if you sleep on your back and don’t get up much during the night. Think about whether or not you want coils.


Interested in learning more about Amerisleep and Saatva? Here are some answers to some of the most often asked questions!

Which mattress is better, Amerisleep or Saatva?

Finding the correct mattress for you is the most important part of the process of purchasing one. Side sleepers with average weight might consider the Amerisleep mattress, while light sleepers may consider the Saatva.

How long will Amerisleep and Saatva mattresses last?

There is no doubt in our minds that both mattresses will survive at least ten years.

Can you flip Amerisleep and Saatva mattresses?

Neither of these mattresses can be flipped. Because the coils at the bottom and the soft foam at the top of both beds make it impossible to flip them, this is a design flaw.

Rate this post