Winkbed vs. Casper Mattress Comparison: Which Is Best? Update 05/2024

There are two prominent bed-in-a-box mattresses that include zonal support: WinkBed and Casper. However, the parallels end there…. When compared to the WinkBed, the Casper is an all-foam mattress. These two different constructions result in two very different sensations that are best suited to various sleepers.

Check out the WinkBed vs. Casper comparison to see which is best for you. then you’ve arrived at the ideal location! If you are looking for a mattress that can help you get a good night’s sleep, this comparison is for you. If you’d rather jump to the end and get the gist of things, you can do so here.

WinkBed vs Casper: Which is Better for You?

One of these beds may work better for you based on your preferred sleeping position, body type, and whether you sleep with a spouse or a pet. Here are a few of my picks for you to consider.

Who Should Buy the WinkBed

  • The WinkBed is a good option if you sleep in a variety of positions. On the Casper, it’s a little bit more difficult to adjust the sleeping position.
  • The WinkBed is the best option if you sleep on your stomach. Firm coil support for stomach sleepers is provided by this mattress.
  • Those who weigh more than 250 pounds should go for the WinkBed, which offers extra support.

Who Should Buy the Casper

  • If you sleep on your side, the Casper mattress may be the ideal option for you. In comparison to the WinkBed, it should be a little softer across the shoulders and hips. However, there is a “Softer” model of the WinkBed that may be a better fit for you.
  • For couples, Casper is the superior option. Although the WinkBed absorbs motion slightly better, this mattress is less likely to disrupt your sleep by your partner’s whims and fancies.
  • For those on a tight budget, Casper mattresses are the best option.

WinkBed vs Casper: Similarities and Differences

WinkBed and Casper appear to have little in common at first glance. But there are a few things they have in common. I’ll begin by pointing out the similarities between them before moving on to the differences. To learn more about the Casper mattress and WinkBeds mattress, I recommend reading the full reviews.

Note: The WinkBed is available in a Softer, Luxury Firm, and Firmer version. In this article, I’ll be talking about the Luxury Firm WinkBed.

Main Similarities

  • A zonal support system is included in the Casper and WinkBed mattresses, with stiffer support in the hips and gentler support in the shoulders. Helps prevent shoulder and back strain for those who sleep on their backs.
  • Casper and WinkBed both have excellent cooling features that should be appealing to overheated sleepers.
  • The WinkBeds is a little more bouncy than the Casper, but both of these mattresses will make you feel like you’re “on top of” them. Check out our top memory foam mattresses instead, if you’re searching for a more conforming feel.
  • It’s hard to tell the difference between the two beds.

Main Differences

  • Unlike the Casper, the WinkBed uses innerspring coils in its construction. You can learn more about Casper’s hybrid mattress in our Casper Hybrid mattress review. My focus here will be on the original foam Casper.
  • The WinkBed’s hybrid structure means that it is bouncier and more supportive than the Casper. This is fantastic news for folks who weigh more than 250 pounds.
  • Compared to the WinkBed, the Casper mattress is less pricey.

WinkBed and Casper Mattress Feel Comparison

Let’s see how these mattresses compare to each other! My firmness test is one of the methods I use to investigate this question. The industry standard for medium firmness is 6.5 on a scale from 1 (extremely soft) to 10 (extra-hard). Because everyone’s perception of firmness is influenced by their body weight, personal tastes, and so on, this range is a little more subjective than it appears. The ratings below are based on my own experiences with these mattresses.


Depending on your preference, you may choose from three different firmness levels for the WinkBed, which I would rate anywhere from a 5 to 7.5 out of 10. A medium-firm WinkBed, the Luxury Firm WinkBed was created to appeal to a wide range of sleepers. On the firmness scale, this mattress received a 7 out of 10, which implies it’s somewhat stiffer than medium-firm.

I found that sinking into the pillow top of the WinkBed provided some excellent pressure relief, but the lift provided by the pocketed coil layer never made me feel stuck. This is a great feel for combo sleepers who need a responsive mattress to easily switch positions in the middle of the night without disturbing their partner.

In addition, I appreciated the bed’s zonal support system, which both raised my hips and cushioned my shoulders from excessive pressure. If you sleep on your back or stomach, this might be a good fit. If you suffer from back pain, this supportive bed could be a good option.


Even though an all-foam mattress could be expected to be extra-soft, I found the Casper to be somewhat harder than medium-firm. This steadfastness is a reflection of the stability it provides in a variety of settings. This hard mattress, like the WinkBed, had a similar bounce to it. However, it was noticeably less bouncy than the WinkBed hybrid.

The Casper’s zonal support system encourages a neutral spinal alignment, while its memory foam contour layer provides some gratifying relaxation at the lumbar region for those who sleep on their stomachs. Choosing a Casper mattress is a good option if you like softer foams to fill in your lower back area.

Side sleepers who don’t mind a firmer feel may also find this bed to be rather comfortable. Additionally, its zoned support system helps alleviate shoulder and hip pain. Side sleepers who experience back pain because their mattress does not allow their shoulders to drop far enough may benefit greatly from this technique. There is a slight difference in shoulder sinkage between the Casper and WinkBed, which these sleepers should take into account.

Comparing What it’s Like to Sleep on the WinkBed and the Casper

Depending on your sleeping position and body type, a mattress will feel different. You can see how each bed feels in various positions, and how I expect it will feel for different weights, in the following paragraphs.


Back — I think the WinkBed is comfortable for back sleepers! A little firmer than medium-firm, this mattress provides excellent lumbar support to keep your spine in an upright position.

Side — Side sleepers are likely to find the WinkBed too firm for their needs. A softer mattress that allows the hips and shoulders to sink into the mattress is ideal for side sleepers.

Stomach — I believe stomach sleepers would enjoy the WinkBed because of its supporting steel coils. The Firmer variant of this mattress is best for stomach sleepers who prefer a firmer feel.

Body Weight — Because light sleepers (those weighing less than 130 lbs.) won’t sink as deeply into the WinkBed as heavier people, it will feel firmer to them. For heavy sleepers (those weighing more than 250 pounds), the mattress will feel softer as they sink deeper into its comfort layer. That said, there is a WinkBed Plus model specifically made for heavy sleepers, which I believe is enough for heavier sleepers.


Back — I really like the Casper for back sleepers! A zonal support system helps to maintain a healthy, straight spinal alignment by providing harder support at the hips and less firm support at the shoulders and feet of the user. Zoned support is a fantastic feature if you have back discomfort, as it can help alleviate it.

Side — Despite my preference for the Casper over the WinkBed for side sleepers, I’d still say this mattress is a little too firm for them. I’d recommend a memory foam mattress for them.

Stomach — When it comes to stomach sleepers I don’t think Casper is the greatest option. In the case of stomach sleepers, however, this bed may be suitable for you if your stomach sleeps for only a portion of the night.

Body Weight — The Casper will certainly be harder for lighter sleepers than I found it to be, and it will likely be softer for heavier sleepers. For heavier folks, I would not recommend the Casper mattress, as it lacks the support they require.

Comparing WinkBed and Casper Prices

When purchasing a new mattress, price is a major concern. However, you can still save money on both mattresses by visiting our Casper mattress coupon and WinkBeds mattress discount pages.

In the table below, you’ll see a comparison of prices for various products. Each size’s pre-discounted pricing is shown in the table.

Comparing WinkBed and Casper Mattress Materials

Here, I’ll break down each mattress’s construction layer-by-layer to give you a better sense of how these mattresses stack up. Below, you’ll learn more about what makes these beds tick.


Cover — The Tencel cover is the first thing you’ll find on the WinkBed. Tencel, a natural fiber noted for its breathability, is used in this mattress to keep you cool at night.

Euro-Pillow Top — Afterwards, you’ll find a soft, gel-infused foam pillow top to relieve pressure spots. Body heat is dissipated through this structure thanks to the gel infusion.

Support Layer — In the end, you’ll come across a coil support system that is pocketed. Individually wrapped steel coils are used to reduce motion transfer in this mattress. There are seven zones of stiffness and pressure relief in this coil design, which can be found at various spots on the body.


Cover — A polyester cover is the first option. Comfortable and warm, it’s on the thin side.

Comfort Layer — There is then a layer of soft, open-cell foam that allows you to sink into the mattress for a little bit of comfort. “Breathing” and “cooling” are two benefits of an open-cell mattress. Motion isolation is a bonus for couples, as is the ability to adjust the firmness.

Contour Layer — There’s even more foam beneath the comfort layer! Additional sinkage and pressure alleviation are provided by a contour layer made of high-quality memory foam.

Transition Layer — Memory foam sits on top of a layer of foam. Once more we’re dealing with an intricately constructed poly foam layer. With its softer shoulders and firmer hips, it’s perfect for side sleepers looking for pressure alleviation and proper spinal alignment. When it comes to support, the Casper mattress uses two poly foam sections instead of seven in the pocketed coil layer of the WinkBed.

Base Layer — High-density polyfoam finishes off the mattress’ construction at the very bottom. The layers above it can rely on this one for solid support.

WinkBed vs Casper: Best Qualities

Finally, we’re nearing the end of our WinkBed vs Casper comparison, which has covered the structure, firmness, and feel of both mattresses. There is now only one question remaining: Which mattress is best for your needs? While I’m unable to provide a response, the material that follows should prove beneficial in making your final decision.

WinkBed Best Features

  • The WinkBed has a good deal of bounce to it. ‘ Those who prefer the sensation of an innerspring mattress as well as combination sleepers, who want some bounce in order to change positions effortlessly, should find it appealing.
  • The WinkBed might be a good option for those in the market for a supportive bed-in-a-box mattress. If you’re looking for a mattress that can accommodate a wide range of body weights, this one is for you.
  • If you’re in the market for a mattress that will last for years, the WinkBed is an excellent option. If you’re looking for a mattress with excellent edge support, this one is for you (which adds to overall durability).

Casper Best Features

  • There are some people who prefer the original Casper mattress because of its well-balanced foam feel, which provides both pressure relief and support.
  • Casper is a great option for those on a budget because of its low price tag!
  • Casper’s zonal support system may be able to alleviate some of your back pain.

Comparing WinkBeds and Casper Customer Service

When you buy a mattress online, you may be concerned about the quality of the company’s customer service. To put your mind at ease, I put the customer service departments of both firms to the test. Below, I’ve given each of them a score out of a possible four: The best, the best, the best, or the worst.

WinkBeds Sleepopolis Customer Service Rating

Great: Quickly, I received an answer to my question via the WinkBeds chat feature. For other mattress companies’ customer service, I’ve had to wait far longer for responses.

Casper Sleepopolis Customer Service Rating

Stellar: Casper’s crew was fantastic to work with. First, I chatted with an agent online and then called Casper’s customer service line and was instantly connected to an agent. Both agents went above and above to be of assistance.

Who the WinkBeds Mattress is Best For 

Best For…

  • Plus-size people: To accommodate larger people, the WinkBed has a plus model that is constructed from sturdy and supportive materials. The WinkBed Plus is an excellent mattress for persons who weigh more than 230 pounds thanks to its high-density foams and sag-resistant latex.
  • Hot sleepers: Excess heat retention is reduced by the WinkBed’s breathable TENCEL cover and innerspring coil layer.
  • Elderly people: Cushioning for the joints and solid spinal support are provided by the WinkBed’s zoned pocketed coils and an additional layer of durable foam along the lumbar spine. The combination of these elements creates a bed that is ideal for senior people who suffer from pain in their joints.

May Not be Best For…

  • Ultra-light sleepers: Innerspring coils are used in the WinkBed’s support system, which makes it a hybrid mattress. You can hear and feel movements on the opposite side of the bed, despite the thick foam layers on top that help to dampen them.
  • Shoppers on a budget: If you’re on a tight budget, the WinkBed might not be the best option.
  • Memory foam mattress fans: Unlike memory foam, the WinkBed lacks the body-hugging properties of the material.

Who the Casper Mattress is Best For 

Best For…

  • Budget shoppers: With a price tag that’s less than the typical new mattress, the Casper is an excellent value.
  • Couples: Since Casper is made entirely of foam, you won’t notice much movement as you move from one side of the bed to the other. For light sleepers who share a bed with a partner, pet, or child, motion isolation is essential..
  • People with lower back pain: Firmer foam fills the center section of the Casper mattress, making it ideal for those who prefer to sleep on their stomach. For those who suffer from lower back discomfort, this can be a huge benefit, since it helps to keep the spine in an optimal position.

May Not be Best For…

  • People who sleep hot: Casper is a mattress made entirely of foam. It retains more heat than most hybrid or innerspring mattresses in spite of their open-cell foam design, which is supposed to improve airflow.
  • People who like a bouncy feel: In order to provide a springy feel to the mattress, Casper does not use steel coils. As opposed to some memory foam beds where you may feel stuck, these don’t have a lot of bounce.
  • Heavyweight folks: People under 230 pounds are best supported by the Casper’s support system and comfort layers.

Rate this post